Regarding Gaucher, like the rest of us I really hope he pans out. Power forwards tend to take more time to develop, so we're probably still at least a few years out from seeing if he becomes a legit option at 3C. That said his rankings last year going into the draft were pretty good overall, I remember Pronman had him at #12 for example.
I think Gaucher was a safe pick like Lundestrom was at the time. Someone with a high floor, low ceiling. The last half of the 1st round is always difficult to draft, honestly I think once you get to pick 20 you're basically in the second round in terms of talent in a lot of drafts. So the Ducks went with a safe character guy who could compliment the rest of the young forward group.
In hindsight they might make a different pick now, but it's usually that way.
I don't think the org makes a different pick, tbh. This is the vision that Verbeek wants into the future, which is to be big, physical, or fast or a combination. Snuggerud and Kulich ranked higher than Gaucher with Central Scouting due to their offensive potential.
Verbeek believes he's got his two top-6 centers set in Zegras and McTavish going into the 2022 draft. He may not believe in Lundestrom as part of the core into the future. From a forward perspective, you being from the middle out and Gaucher fills out the top-9 centers of the future. Snuggerud is a RW and Kulich is smaller center.
Gaucher is a best fit selection than a best player available at the time of the draft. This happens all the time the further you are from the #1 pick. In the 2019 draft, we passed up winger Kaliyev for LW Tracey at 29th overall. Kaliyev has instant chemistry with Zegras, who we picked 9th overall in that same draft. In 2020, we course corrected and drafted BPA than best fit with Perreault at 27th overall. Perreault, like Kaliyev, dropped in the draft due to low motor drive on defense. Yet, both Tracey and Perreault were top-6 scorer swings for the old regime.
Going into this draft, Verbeek said he'll focus on forwards. This is a course correction to want to get more top-6 scoring forward types, especially since both Tracey and Perreault had a not so great season in San Diego this past year. Grabbing Fantilli helps, but we're still missing two more top-6 forwards.