Well thought out post. But I WOULD counter with don't count out Newhook as our 2nd line center going forward. Here are my reasons:
1. He's just turned 21. There is so much room to develop & grow, particularly with guys like Landeskog, Lehkonen, Nichushkin and Rantanen possibly playing with him.
2. This season was his first "real" season with us, and he's scored 33 points in 71 games (or on pace for 38 points), plus 11. In my view, for a first year, that's excellent. In perspective:
- Rantanen first year 38 points in 75 games, minus 25
- Landeskog first year 52 points in 82 games, plus 20
- Lehkonen first year 28 points in 73 games, minus 1
- Nichushkin first year 34 points in 79 games, plus 20
3. Progression. While Alex scoring was pretty inconsistent to begin with (which is natural in his first season), in his last 14 games, when we were amping up for the playoffs, he scored 10 points (or on pace for 59 points)
4. Linemates. Despite me disagreeing with most, people thought our bottom 6 left a lot to be desired. Well, Newhook got the results he did regardless. Quarter one, he played most with Jost, NAK, LOC, quarter two, the same. Quarter three, NAK, LOC, JT and started getting time with Kadri / Bura, then the last quarter, Sturm, NAK, LOC and got a LITTLE more time with Kadri / Bura. This shows better line-mates, better scoring as the trends suggests. THEN consider the step up AGAIN, playing with as I said, Landy, Lehk, Nuke and Rants. That 59 point pace he had to finish the season may be shattered - and my view he could pace 60-70 points, at the age of 21.
5. Experience. If say he doesn't suffer the proverbial sophomore slump (it happens), he's just come out of a campaign including some of the most intense, stressed situation games, which ALWAYS bodes well for learning and experience. He'll have so much more confidence then going into normal season proper games where every single play isn't life or death.
Mate, in my view, Newhook has all the tools. Wheels, potential, drive, compete. He plays well now both sides of the ice. Let's not give him away so easily. The way he was trending, with "good" players tells me he could excel with AMAZING players.
Sorry for the long winded response. The kid could be anything.
PS: Quarterly line-mate stats taken from:
Alex Newhook - Fantasy Hockey Game Logs, Advanced Stats and more - Frozen Tools