Alright, here is what I said about Moore, since I think critics are getting misconstrued:
Late November:
"I'm usually a Trevor Moore apologist. I see great value in his game even when he's not scoring but like you point out the issue is how many of those guys do you need?
You can see it when we're on the PP--the risk-averse nature of the roster building means you just have a bunch of two-way guys and no 'offensive specialists' outside Durzi. You could easily have room on the roster for at least one line of maybe more risky offensive guys that you can deploy in PP situations or in the Ozone. That's what I was under the impression Danault was for--him and Kopitar eat the hard minutes so the youth don't have to--and that really just hasn't been the case outside of Kupari but that's not exactly high octane offense, he's a Trevor Lewis. Still blows my mind that Vilardi has had harder starts than Danault. Like what in the world. "
Late December:
"Moore's offensive inconsistencies are why he's a bottom sixer not a top sixer. See Trevor Lewis.
He's still doing everything right and creating turnovers and supporting the puck so would be hard to displace him , the points will come.
Edit: yep looking up the metrics and he just has some absolute shit luck right now which I think matches the eye test, only a matter of time till stuff starts going in. Lowest real on-ice shooting % on the team, some bad goaltending luck too, he's got an xGF% of 58% which is highest for forwards on the team and an actual GF% that's nearly lowest on the team lol, that's gonna reconcile to some degree soon, hope it starts tonight!
"
There was also a point in there where he WAS having a bad couple of weeks after not scoring a bunch but started turning the puck over a lot too, looked tired, couldn't carry OR forecheck. I called for him to be benched for a game or two several times. No, he WAS NOT playing the exact same, hence the difference in opinion. Its' like Lizotte last year too--some people are getting painted like they were trying to get either of these two guys traded when really it was 1. Okay you're not scoring and that's fine, that's not truly your role but 2. you're not currently good at your actual role either so it's time to take a breath.
Don't confuse benching a bad run of play for GTFO.
TLDR playing good and pucks going in now now doesn't mean the critics of his play weren't right at some point.