I don't think anyone thinks Trevor Moore is fine right now.
Andersson is a mixed bag but between injuries and constant movement between ontario and LA it's understandable. When he gets a few games in a row he gets in a good rhthym. However yes, he has been mostly 3rd/4th line.
Clague, maybe I seem higher on him than I am, I think he's a #4-#6 guy on a good team, probably #5-7 on a good playoff team. My problem with Clague is the organizations evaluation of him and constantly jerking him around. He's also a different skillset than the guys we've had the last few years and is an excellent puck mover and good at wheeling it around. I'd like more goals, sure, but he puts up good points with his playmaking and skating. And also--keep in mind he's done all this with 1. an organization that clearly has no faith in him; 2. rarely gets put in positions to succeed--his most common partners have been MacDermid (ON THE 2ND f***ING PAIRING) and Maatta. This year, with Maatta, he's 44% CF and 33% GF; without he is 52% CF and 50% GF despite harder minutes. Tell me what you think is really up there. Doesn't matter though, guess which one they kept?
Durzi--I've constantly said I don't think he's an NHLer and if anything he's showing he can be a Marc-Andre Bergeron type. Good for him. But if anything he's a different look than the 7 clone two-way 6 foot dmen we have. Im starting to be convinced if TM could have 7 Olli Maattas he would.
Kupari--again I'm not high on him and yeah he needs some NHL time but a once-highly-thought of guy who led the AHL team in scoring is now being used as a checker.
You're also ignoring the KEY players--
Kaliyev--they're doing their best to turn him into Dwight King. Don't be surprised if he turns out to be a 'responsible' middling 20 goal guy to make TM happy instead of being used as a f***ing weapon.
Vilardi--turns out 4C was a bad option for him. Who knew? Oh, f***ing everyone else.
Turcotte--think they just straight up forgot him.
Byfield--sure sure he made the team but they were going to start him at 4C...look at how our 4Cs have been deployed this year.
JAD--playing waiver games with him like they were with Clague.
Not to mention Fagemo et. al.
I think it's an absolutely legitimate concern to see how all of the above are used, deployed, and evaluated and worry about the next (more important) wave. When no one is exceeding expectations...are you going to blame all the prospects and say hey we overrated every single f***ing one of them? OR at some point are we going to hold coaching, development accountable.
I was naive to think the Danault signing would actually be used to alleviate kopitars usage and insulate kids. I also thought maybe kids outplaying vets would mean the spots were theirs--nope. Zero accountability for the skating pianos on the team, but kids get absolutely trashed for a turnover. They have 100% gone against verbalized philosophy and maybe I made too many inferences and had too much faith. This is some of the worst mismanagement of vision I have seen in the NHL maybe ever. Are we going to keep punishing Byfield for trying creative things until he's just an up and down on rails bubble hockey player like everyone else?
Let me just say I think Maatta sucks as much as anyone else on the board.
![laugh :laugh: :laugh:](/styles/default/xenforo/smilies/laff.gif)
I absolutely agree on the key guys. I don't think where Kaliyev is right now is best for his arc, but really he does poorly with tough matchups. He's learning, getting key PP time, is out at end of games, and so on. So I'm not that worried. I don't think they are trying to turn him into Dwight, just having him focus on things he needs to. Right now he's not finishing regardless so his 4th line deployment isn't that far off. But he's not an energy guy and wilts against strong competition right now, so the top 3 lines might be counter productive. I also agree they've been missing the obvious with Gabe, but his production and COVID warrated some AHL time anyways. JAD should be up, no question to me. Turcotte needs to get a look too, it might make decisions a lot easier if he shows what he can do.
This is why I don't worry about those middling guys that will be waived, they aren't long for the organization anyways. I can see spots for Kaliyev, Grundy, Turcotte, Byfield, Vilardi, and JAD when the team starts to make noise. The other guys, not so much.