Long Live Lyle
Registered User
I don’t think he would’ve been in on Gusev if he was comfortable.
Speculation: 2019 offseason thread IV
- Thread starter Doggy
- Start date
- Status
I don’t think he would’ve been in on Gusev if he was comfortable.
- Jan 12, 2011
- 14,422
- 10,856
Probably a bit of armchair GM, but I'd have sure liked to have back those two 2nd round picks used/wasted on Dzingel for risk-taking on Gusev.
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Less armchair, more hindsight. Dzingel being essentially useless was kind of a rude surprise; he seemed ready-made for a spot next to Duchene seeing as though he'd been doing it all year.
But yeah, given the way things turned out, I'd have preferred a try with Gusev as well.
Teams that have forwards to spare via trade (depth/cap reasons/etc):
Toronto
Montreal
Calgary
St. Louis
Tampa
Winnipeg
Not a long list of teams there. And less have a need for D. I don’t see a high likelihood for any major trades to bring in a top-6 forward happening this offseason.
Toronto
Montreal
Calgary
St. Louis
Tampa
Winnipeg
Not a long list of teams there. And less have a need for D. I don’t see a high likelihood for any major trades to bring in a top-6 forward happening this offseason.
Iron Balls McGinty
Registered User
- Aug 5, 2005
- 9,163
- 7,244
I think there is a difference in being comfortable and always trying to make your team better.
Long Live Lyle
Registered User
There are likely at least a couple others. Florida for example comes immediately to mind. Wouldn’t be surprised if there are more. Plus you just never know if there’s a team that really likes a certain player, even if they appear mostly set on D.
Long Live Lyle
Registered User
Fair. Although I think he’s less likely to “try to make the team better” at defense.
It’s probably a middle ground. I don’t think he’s panicking (if he was, he would’ve found a way to beat that NJD offer for Gusev) but I highly doubt he’s as confident in the F corps as the D. He might not be uncomfortable about the forwards, but I highly doubt he is comfortable, either, like the way he is about the D.
Idk about Florida, the only forward I see them thinking about moving is Hoffman because he’s in the last year of his contract. If they were able to get the B+B combo on July 1, then different story. No way they consider moving Huberdeau/Trochek.
Sure something could come out of left field (we’ve seen it happen a few times before), I just don’t think anything will happen because of the logjam of high profile RFAs yet to be signed and the high amount of defensemen already rumored to being on the market.
Could have kept Duclair around too. Would give Sonny a partner in the "offensively skilled, doesn't display enough D for Torts" doghouse.
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Leave off the "for Torts" and it's accurate. Duclair has worn out his welcome with many, many coaches before he came to Tortorella in an attempt to learn to do better. Milano obviously doesn't have that same track record of bouncing from team to team, but he seems to have a similar mental block w/r/d the other half of the ice going.
Or to be more blunt about it - it's not a Tortorella problem.
- Jan 12, 2011
- 14,422
- 10,856
Partially true, but......While many coaches struggle with these type players, think it's clear Torts has even less tolerance for this style and Dzingel is a not so dissimilar player. His healthy scratch in the playoffs was because he was seeing visions of Duclair. Dzingel would never have proven nearly as successful here as during his time in Ottawa.
I'll add I wasn't a huge fan of Dzingel but I do believe his short time in Columbus and inability to adapt cost him $1M AAV this summer.
Yeah, I don't know if I would have let Dzingle walk. We tend to take on charity cases and he would have fit right in.... :p
I don't know he's wasn't all that good but he only got a two year deal. I'd have been ok with that deal and maybe moved him at the deadline if he didn't rebound. I don't really like rentals and wasting assets like that, but what do I know? I figured he was the one that would have been most likely to stay when all this went down at the deadline. He's probably going to be decent in Carolina.
We can say what we want about our coaching, but certain coaches tend to get more out of their players than others. I can't really say Torts is really in that category.
pled
Registered User
- Sep 7, 2009
- 3,048
- 891
Derick Brassard, Devante Smith-Pelly, maybe Marko Dano. It's a scrap heap, for sure. I'd pick these guys because you could tell in a span of a couple weeks at camp whether they've turned the corner. Does Brass still have it in him? Is DSP going to fight harder to be a full time NHLer? I think we'd find out relatively quickly whether these guys could improve on last year.
CBJWerenski8
Rest in Peace Johnny
- Jun 13, 2009
- 43,640
- 26,674
His price is what you'd expect for a very good second pair D, not a third pair guy.
Aren't you guys supposed to prefer our scraps?
Richard88
John 3:16
- Jun 29, 2019
- 19,405
- 21,152
pled
Registered User
- Sep 7, 2009
- 3,048
- 891
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Before he went to you guys, we were discussing with Toronto a Savard-for-Kadri one-for-one.
Richard88
John 3:16
- Jun 29, 2019
- 19,405
- 21,152
That's interesting.
For the record, I didn't mean that Savard is a bottom-pairing defenseman quality wise. That's just where he'd be on our blueline given that we already have Makar and Johnson. With the capspace we have it would be really nice to stack the defense with a big upgrade at 3rd pairing RHD.
Double-Shift Lasse
Just post better
Fair enough, as long as you understand that's not his value/price.
Jovavic
Concept of a Plan
If Jarmo doesn't trade a D for a F for whatever reason, could we see Torts deploy 11F 7D on most nights? I can't think of a team that's done so, but the strength and depth of the D far outclasses the depth of the Fs
Nyquist
Cam
PLD
Foligno
Jenner
Anderson
Bjorkstrand
Nash
Wennberg
Dubinsky
Texier
Robinson
Milano
Jones
Werenski
Savard
Nuti
Murray
Gavrikov
Kukan
Harrington
I know I would like Kukan out there as the extra D than playing someone like Robinson or Milano five minutes a night just to complete a line
I may have missed some players, my mind isn't as sharp as it used to be lol. The F list for me assumes that Bemstrom shows he's not ready and goes back to Sweden for the year.
Nyquist
Cam
PLD
Foligno
Jenner
Anderson
Bjorkstrand
Nash
Wennberg
Dubinsky
Texier
Robinson
Milano
Jones
Werenski
Savard
Nuti
Murray
Gavrikov
Kukan
Harrington
I know I would like Kukan out there as the extra D than playing someone like Robinson or Milano five minutes a night just to complete a line
I may have missed some players, my mind isn't as sharp as it used to be lol. The F list for me assumes that Bemstrom shows he's not ready and goes back to Sweden for the year.
I don't think we'd do that because it wouldn't substitute any F minutes for D minutes. It would just be the #7D taking minutes from the other D, and more minutes for the 11 F's.
Double-Shift Lasse
Just post better
Agreed so the real question is: Is any of the D depth better at forward that the forward depth. I’d guess the answer there, whether we like it or not or might like to entertain the notion, is no.
- Status
