- Mar 9, 2002
- 7,204
- 4,942
Maybe on the pp but 5/5 that’s horrible balance, 2 guys that are average skaters (Vilardi/Kaliyev) and two that are not known for their defensive play (Frk/Kaliyev). If you leave Kempe there instead of Kaliyev it drastically improves the make up of the line and we have already seen that Frk, Vilardi and Kempe can play together. I think you let them pick up from where they left off.
Kaliyev is an interesting one for next year. He’s too good for Junior, but has fundamentals he needs to improve to make the NHL. The current shutdown does give him (and others) a great opportunity to work on conditioning, so he can improve that but the rest of it requires ice time.
I don’t see Kaliyev playing a bottom 6 role, it just isn’t him. His skill set is all offensive and he’s never going to be a great 2 way forward, but offensively he could end up our best player one day. So if he makes the NHL next year the only spot for him on day one IMO is on Kopitar’s right side as he will need a good defensive centre that can also get the most out of his offensive skill set. He has the talent, but is he going to be ready? Given the Covid situation I’m not confident but maybe it would be worth a gamble. He won’t play with Vilardi (certainly not initially) and the other options are probably between Carter, Turcotte and Lizotte. You could make a case for Carter but his game isn’t reliable enough IMO to play alongside a rookie with some big questions about his defensive game. So if they give him a 9 game look it would have to be alongside Kopitar for me. Trying him with Kopitar and Iafallo would be a good balance and would be the best chance for Kaliyev to stick. His minutes could still be managed by having Brown step up as required, given his natural understanding with Kopi, so Kaliyev can still be protected easily when he has inevitable issues with tough match ups etc. It would be a gamble but if it works the pay off would be huge.
I personally don’t think he makes the NHL next year, except maybe the first 9 games. However IF he does I think it’s because he hits it off with the skipper. I love the kid and I think he has serious potential but they really need to make sure they handle his development very carefully.
Foe a few games I would not mind seeing
Iafallo - Kopitar - Kaliyev - Iafallo meshes w Kopi and does a ton of the dirty work, Kopi is top 3 best 2 way players in NHL, Kaliyev just has to get in position and shoot
Kempe - Vilardi - Frk - Liked what I saw so far
Carter - Turcotte - Brown - Don't think Turcotte is ready but give him a taste surrounded by two vets to protect him .
Grundstrom - Lizotte - Wagner
Moore -Amadio - Porky - spares, Amadio probably ends up replacing Turcotte
Bjornfot - Doughty
Edmundson - Walker - Signin a big body w playoff experience to help protect our smaller core, is young, and eats minutes without being a liability
Anderson - Roy
MacDermid - As ther is 2 rooks in the lineup that could also use spells of MacDermid gets 50 ish games, cherry pick his games against bigger lineups and problems like Tkachuk
Quick - Mentor
Peterson - up and coming protege