The second point is really good.
The first, I don't even know if I even disagree. It's not conclusive either way for me. And we agree it's case by case. I think we could audit dudes all night, haha. Like I said, I don't know if it would make Pasta better or worse to have waited. You seem to feel that time in the NHL environment is better, I personally GENERALLY feel it's better for them to dominate a lower level. and again, I've run it a few times, just going to plagiarize myself:
"It's not at all surprising to me that most of those guys aren't on the roster as of yet, and while some of the guys that are are a surprise, it's a pleasant surprise, not an indictment of drafting. The number of 18-20 year olds in the NHL is incredibly small and especially so for organizations that don't rush prospects.
Edit: here's the list of 18-20 year olds and why it's no surprise. Guys in parentheses have gotten less than half games:
2001 bday: Three regulars--Hughes, Kakko, Dach. (Bjornfot, Heinola have gotten a taste).
2000 bday: Four regulars--Kotkaniemi, Dahlin, Svechnikov, Farabee. (Dobson, Sandin, Gustafsson, Hayton, Wahlstrom, Boqvist have gotten a taste)
1999 bday: Twelve regulars--Hughes, Tkachuk, Texier, Chytil, Brannstrom, Suzuki, Heiskanen, Thomas, Jokiharju, Glass, Necas, Comtois, Hischier. Only 5 have played all their teams games. 10 more have gotten a cup of coffee.
We have this expectation that tons of guys jump right into the NHL but as I've pointed out before it's usually after 21 when guys break through--as they are typically finishing first year or so of college and last year of so or junior and/or one year of professional hockey at home or overseas. There were only 19 18-20 year old regulars so far this season--there are
23 21-year-old regulars, and an additional 28 who have gotten cups of coffee."
Here are the 21 year olds playing this year that played extensively in the NHL prior to this year:
Laine, Chychrun, Keller, PLD, Sergachev, Girard, Jost, Bratt, Mete, Patrick, (Poolparty), Pettersson, Middlestadt, Howden.
NHL Players Born in 1998 for the rest.
My point overall is only why rush them? There's a long list of dudes who got plugged into slots too soon and either plateaued or only developed one side of their game. Fair, some guys never figure it out, and in some ways it's a chicken-or-egg question, but i look at the list of never-was-es and the guys that did it and succeeded is small, and those that reached their potential is very, VERY small. Why chance it? If the guy can't beat Trevor Lewis for a roster spot, let him wait. The list of
successful 18-20 year olds is tiny.