deeshamrock
Registered User
There is a chasm between "taking the team apart" and making intelligent, forward thinking decisions. Lombardi's big crime was hubris. He believed in his team so much that not only did he not prepare for the flexibility needed in event of failure, he doubled down on it and made it damn near impossible to avoid.
That possibility that the window would close prematurely was very easy to predict in 2015, not just because of missing the playoffs, but because of the sheer number of longterm contract extensions that guaranteed roster stagnation. I don't care how good the message is, you need fresh blood to come in and liven up not only the room, but different players to add different wrinkles to the same system.
It was very easy to see that the failure of 2015 wasn't just due to physical exhaustion, but also apathy. Continued failure was the most likely outcome. And by failure, I don't mean suddenly becoming a lottery team overnight, but in terms of Cup contention ending. So when the Brown extension was offered, some thought it was too damn long for a player who you would have already traded if Nash decided to waive. Signing Gaborik was a major mistake and argued against by the same folks for the same reasons. Too much time for a player known to lose focus who couldn't remain healthy that took him too late into his career
The Lucic deal was probably the worst trade in the history of the franchise. It was known from day 1 that he could never be re-signed, only Lombardi's hubris lead him to think it was possible. That trade strip-mined an already desolate asset list.
That was why so many argued so strongly against Kopitar's ridiculous extension. It was suicide. He HAD to be traded in order to salvage the next half decade from the black hole. He would never be worth that money in years 5-8, and at least the first two would be worthless during a rebuild/retool, whatever you want to call it, because the team clearly can't challenge now. It was so easy to see, but Dean was sure he knew better. He didn't, he was wrong, it cost the team dearly now and for the next few seasons, and it cost him his job.
It was always the most likely outcome, and some of us explained why we thought so thoroughly in 2015.
Yes there is. Great statement, entire post was well thought out and spot on.