Maybe you like the way Muzzin runs hot and cold but for my taste I would like someone more solid and Carlson fits the bill and is a few years younger... I think we can both agree we have a nice influx of forward talent that will come up over the next 2-3 seasons but we sorely lack that talent on the defensive end...
Carlson also allows Martinez to go back to his natural position at a premium of $2.5-$3 million... add the fact that JC is pretty damn good on the PP and we help solve another team weakness...
Speaking for myself, the Kings are built around Doughty, Quick and Kopitar... then, Toffoli, Pearson, Kempe...
As for your assessment that signing Carlson and trading Muzzin doesn’t really solve anything.. well the fact is Carlson is much, much better than Muzzin and as I stated above he would help improve current weaknesses of the team.. Doughty can carry anyone as can Carlson so possibly having Martinez on the 3rd pairing would go a long way toward solidifying our defensive Corps.
Its not about Muzz vs Carlson/whomever, in a vacuum. It's about having Muzz, now. He is a top 4 D, much to the chagrin of some of our fans. A top 4 D on a sweetheart deal. We need to add to DD, Mart, Muzz, not trade them.
My original post that you replied to was about AMart, tho. Not Muzz. AMart is a stud. Certified. For his size and being LH, he is so efficient. It would be a monumental mistake to trade him. Who is always the last to greet Quick after every game? AMart is a huge part of this team. Especially now that players like Stoll, Richards, Mitchell etc are gone. Muzz, too, with that sexy AAV.
No one would ever argue with you on whom the heart of our team is. We all know that.
My thing is, mon frère, that we need to add to the core of DD, Muzz, Amart, not trade them and still find ourselves in need of another top-4 D. I feel like our FWD depth is fine once Carter comes back, and with Vilardi apparently only a season away, plus the emergence of Kempe.
Keep our picks, our top 3 D, and Vilardi. If we want another D, trade from other sources, imo.
Also,
thanks for being tactful this time. Kill em with kindness.