Proposal: 2013 Offseason: UFAs, Trades, and Potential Buyouts | Part II

Status
Not open for further replies.

mcnorth

Registered User
Jun 28, 2011
4,266
3
Or every time someone wants to trade Cowen, show some 'highlights' of Chara wearing a NY Islanders uniform or getting eaten alive by the Lightning in the playoffs when he was here.

Patience. Kid is already good.
 

WhiteLight*

Guest
Young core that is not moving

Lehner

Karlsson
Cowen

Zibanejad
Turris
Silfverberg
 

Security Guard Chang*

Guest
I think the problem is we far overvalue our prospects and undervalue other teams' players. Talking about Cowen as a norris nominee after his putrid playoffs and his average first year highlights that.

I would do Cowen and a 1st for Voracek, but I doubt that Philly would. Although I would save that package for a winger that is more of a goal scorer like Eriksson or Ryan.

average first year? um what? as a rookie D-man cowen surpassed all expectations while also flaunting off some serious top end potential.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Qward

Because! That's why!
Jul 23, 2010
19,036
6,069
Behind you, look out
Keep personal attacks out this.

You can disagree with the post and the poster, you cannot insult them.

If this continues, thread bans will be issued.
 

mcnorth

Registered User
Jun 28, 2011
4,266
3
How can members of this board, who so vehemently argued how much more important a top four defenseman was than a top six forward was just last offseason (see: Methot/Foligno) now argue so vehemently the counterpoint? Really shows a lot of the 'philosophies' are more convenience than considered.

That said, last year I wanted to keep Foligno and now I want to keep Cowen. So yeah. :facepalm: Internet ramblings are internet ramblings. Keep Cowen. Nice move for Methot.
 

BK201

Registered User
Apr 11, 2011
10,818
316
I think people underestimate Gryba's value. He's big, mobile, physical, good shot, RD with a right hand shot, extremely cheap RFA. Guys like Gryba do not grow on trees and he had a really good rookie campaign.

IMO I think Gryba is probably the most movable defenseman with mid pairing upside.

The right hand shot alone brings value and that hit against Montreal says a lot.
 

aragorn

Do The Right Thing
Aug 8, 2004
29,280
9,984
I think people underestimate Gryba's value. He's big, mobile, physical, good shot, RD with a right hand shot, extremely cheap RFA. Guys like Gryba do not grow on trees and he had a really good rookie campaign.

IMO I think Gryba is probably the most movable defenseman with mid pairing upside.

The right hand shot alone brings value and that hit against Montreal says a lot.

I agree, there is no reason to move Gryba until someone better comes along. Ceci is also a RD but who knows how long before he is NHL ready? My own opinion is sooner rather than later & he will fit in nicely behind Karlsson & just ahead of Gryba on the right side one day. There is also Rutkoski on the right side but he will need at least a full yr in Bingo if not longer & may never be an NHLer. Of course, this draft it`s likely they add another defenceman or two.

On the left side there is Methot, Cowen & Wiercioch should be playing there in Ottawa, Phillips & Benoit as fill-ins & Boroweicki as the first call-up for the left side. If Sdao continues to develop quickly he will be hard to keep off the roster with his size & toughness, could be a yr or less away. There is always the option of trading for a top 4 defenceman but they are expensive & rare especially on the right side.

Two yrs from now:
Methot - Karlsson
Cowen - Ceci
Wiercioch - Gryba/Sdao replaces Wiercioch against the tougher teams.
 

Pavlikovsky

Registered User
May 31, 2013
1,000
294
Gatineau, QC
I agree, there is no reason to move Gryba until someone better comes along. Ceci is also a RD but who knows how long before he is NHL ready? My own opinion is sooner rather than later & he will fit in nicely behind Karlsson & just ahead of Gryba on the right side one day. There is also Rutkoski on the right side but he will need at least a full yr in Bingo if not longer & may never be an NHLer. Of course, this draft it`s likely they add another defenceman or two.

On the left side there is Methot, Cowen & Wiercioch should be playing there in Ottawa, Phillips & Benoit as fill-ins & Boroweicki as the first call-up for the left side. If Sdao continues to develop quickly he will be hard to keep off the roster with his size & toughness, could be a yr or less away. There is always the option of trading for a top 4 defenceman but they are expensive & rare especially on the right side.

Two yrs from now:
Methot - Karlsson
Cowen - Ceci
Wiercioch - Gryba/Sdao replaces Wiercioch against the tougher teams.

Wiercioch has top 4 potential why would we put him on the third parring.
 

aragorn

Do The Right Thing
Aug 8, 2004
29,280
9,984
Wiercioch has top 4 potential why would we put him on the third parring.

Don't all young guys start at the bottom & work their way up? Doesn't he have to prove he can handle the minutes & the tougher competition? Doesn't he have to earn it before they give it to him? I think so, but I also agree that he has 2nd pairing potential. I think he will start next season paired with Phillips & Phillips playing the right side & Wiercioch can work his way up from there.
 

BondraTime

Registered User
Nov 20, 2005
29,685
25,315
East Coast
Don't all young guys start at the bottom & work their way up? Doesn't he have to prove he can handle the minutes & the tougher competition? Doesn't he have to earn it before they give it to him? I think so, but I also agree that he has 2nd pairing potential. I think he will start next season paired with Phillips & Phillips playing the right side & Wiercioch can work his way up from there.

Don't you have Ceci in your top four?
 

aragorn

Do The Right Thing
Aug 8, 2004
29,280
9,984
Don't you have Ceci in your top four?

No, I think he starts the season in Bingo but at some point in the season likely before the trade deadline I think he finds his way to Ottawa. I think eventually he will be in the top 4 behind Karlsson on the right side replacing Gonchar depending only on how long it takes for him to get there.
 

BK201

Registered User
Apr 11, 2011
10,818
316
Phillips won't be used as a spare. Unless he really falls off he won't be scratched either for Sdao tbh.

As for the RD Ceci from what I've heard probably won't play this year and the value in the right D is the right hand shot.

If they could get Gryba to play second pp unit it's a tool not a lot of teams have.
 

ReginKarlssonLehner

Let's Win It All
May 3, 2010
40,932
11,394
Dubai Marina
Watching Wiercioch develop and turn his game around, I think he has top pairing potential, which I've seen him capable of after that brilliant performance in NCAA. Kind of like how McDonagh developed later than people expected.

People who didn't want Wier in the A this year wouldn't catch my drift. He was the best all-around defender, simply brilliant both ends of the ice with at least one amazing end-to-end rush a game.

His offensive ability is already good enough for the NHL but if he can fix up his defensive tendencies he'll be an elite top 4.
 

Karl Cowensson

I has cheezburger
Oct 27, 2008
2,214
0
Northern Ontario
Wiercioch has top 4 potential why would we put him on the third parring.

Because he's young and inexperienced. Next year he's probably on the bottom pairing with Phillips and will see sheltered minutes and PP time. Cowen will probably anchor the second pair with whoever replaces Gonchar.

Can't stress how good Cowen is, it's a miracle he played at all this season, can't put too much stock into his play this season when he wasn't 100%. If keeps playing that way next year we'll talk, but I have a feeling he'll be much improved to start the season.
 

YNWA14

Onbreekbaar
Dec 29, 2010
34,543
2,560
I see a lot of similarities between Luke Schenn and Jared Cowen. Especially in the way that they're being talked about. Not necessarily in their skillsets.

average first year? um what? as a rookie D-man cowen surpassed all expectations while also flaunting off some serious top end potential.

He had an average first year. As in he didn't wow like a Jonas Brodin, and he wasn't terrible. He was steady for the most part and was a serviceable 4th defenceman. This year he was worse than that, but obviously had an excuse. With that said, he's a long ways away from being compared to Chara or being "untouchable" on this team.
 

sens2k9

Registered User
Aug 8, 2008
1,098
10
Because he's young and inexperienced. Next year he's probably on the bottom pairing with Phillips and will see sheltered minutes and PP time. Cowen will probably anchor the second pair with whoever replaces Gonchar.

Can't stress how good Cowen is, it's a miracle he played at all this season, can't put too much stock into his play this season when he wasn't 100%. If keeps playing that way next year we'll talk, but I have a feeling he'll be much improved to start the season.

Historically when plyers return from injury (especially when they return "early") they have a great first week-and-a-half. After that the adrenaline is gone and the lack of game-fitness really shows.
 
Last edited:

DrakeAndJosh

Intangibles
Jun 19, 2010
11,863
1,781
Kanata
I see a lot of similarities between Luke Schenn and Jared Cowen. Especially in the way that they're being talked about. Not necessarily in their skillsets.



He had an average first year. As in he didn't wow like a Jonas Brodin, and he wasn't terrible. He was steady for the most part and was a serviceable 4th defenceman. This year he was worse than that, but obviously had an excuse. With that said, he's a long ways away from being compared to Chara or being "untouchable" on this team.

One thing I saw from Cowen this season that he seemed to be lacking the season before was a mean streak. He has all the tools and I'm pretty confident next season he'll show why he was a top 5 projection.
 

Micklebot

Moderator
Apr 27, 2010
56,708
34,507
One thing I saw from Cowen this season that he seemed to be lacking the season before was a mean streak. He has all the tools and I'm pretty confident next season he'll show why he was a top 5 projection.




It was there, just needed to see it more consistently. Also worth mentioning, for the playoffs at least, we were facing 2 of the better Power play teams in the league, he may have been told by the coaching staff to ease up on that type of stuff for fear of getting penalties.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad