Tundra
Registered User
- Oct 20, 2005
- 10,393
- 1,394
Lou has been pretty up and down since the lockout (the 04/05 lockout). Hes had some good years and some bad ones. We were in cap hell for a few seasons which was because of the horrendous Mogilny, Malakhov, McGillis contracts in 06/07 and then in 2011 mainly because of the Rolston contract. We couldn't even ice a full damn team at the start of that season because our cap was a mess. We were icing 11 forwards for a few weeks which is completely inexcusable. Having said that he has been much better recently. The Sykora, Bernier, Carter, Poni, Lokti, Hedberg, D'Agostini pickups were all solid in my opinion. We shall what happens with Sullivan. I have a good feeling hes gonna help us down the stretch here. Lets also not forgot about Zubrus who has been outstanding for us. I've loved signing him since the day it happened back in 07. The Salvador, Tallinder, Volchenkov contracts are pretty bad but at the time we had no options but to sign the Euro's because Martin walked so we had to replace him. Salvador was phenominal during the playoffs and we obviously knew he was gonna get paid but the length of the deal I have a problem with.
My biggest beef with him which has been mentioned many times on here is the decision to go with Tedenby, Josefson, Butler, Matteau, and Barch instead of picking up a few guys via FA that would have much better and safer. I know people say "Well who hell was available? Semin was never coming here." I think someone like Parenteau would have worked out well. Hudler as well. Those guys wouldnt have killed our cap and would have been decent fits here. Now if what some people have said is true about Vanderbeek and him having no money this past summer then I guess that negates that argument but I dont think I believe that.
In the end hes whiffed on a few signings, trades, and draft picks but what GM hasn't? You cant hit a home run on everything you do. We went to freaking finals last year and got HUGE contributions from guys Lou picked up. We have made the playoffs every year except twice since 95. Thats pretty damn good
Lou is a good GM now, as opposed to the great one he used to be, when the rest of the league was absolutely confounded by the devils methodology in terms of finding and developing top-flight talent. There is no shame in pointing that out.