Toggle sidebar

12'/13' Draft Thread: Offensive flash is a beauty but defensive presence rules.

  • Xenforo Cloud will be upgrading us to version 2.3.5 on March 3rd at 12 AM GMT. This version has increased stability and fixes several bugs. We expect downtime for the duration of the update. The admin team will continue to work on existing issues, templates and upgrade all necessary available addons to minimize impact of this new version. Click Here for Updates
Status
Not open for further replies.
leugangen said:
The only real issue I have with this is that Nichushkin is before Barkov/Lindholm, and this is coming from someone that loves Nichushkin more than most.
Click to expand...

What is Nichushkin's contract status? I read somewhere that he signed a 3 year khl contract in 2012...that could drop him out of the first round I think.
 
Sundinisagod said:
What is Nichushkin's contract status? I read somewhere that he signed a 3 year khl contract in 2012...that could drop him out of the first round I think.
Click to expand...

I don't know why that would be a problem. Kulemin signed an extension in Russia before coming over.

Draft at 18, Burke always leaves them in junior 1-2 years, 1 year in AHL and then audition for the NHL. Total time 3 years.
 
ULF_55 said:
I don't know why that would be a problem. Kulemin signed an extension in Russia before coming over.

Draft at 18, Burke always leaves them in junior 1-2 years, 1 year in AHL and then audition for the NHL. Total time 3 years.
Click to expand...

It doesn't seem like a problem for me either, but it seems to be the reason he's outside the top 10 on most draft lists...maybe the fear is the player will get extended to a lucrative contract over there instead of coming here and fighting for a job, possibly spending time in the AHL etc...
 
Sundinisagod said:
It doesn't seem like a problem for me either, but it seems to be the reason he's outside the top 10 on most draft lists...maybe the fear is the player will get extended to a lucrative contract over there instead of coming here and fighting for a job, possibly spending time in the AHL etc...
Click to expand...

Well the NHL should have to compete for the best players.

I know there is always the fear they won't come over, but you have to select who you think is the best option and make it work.
 
I still really want Monahan.

Mackinnon or Monahan would be my dream pick. I'd think that they'd both go back down to Juniors again next year and will make team Canada.

Would be fun to watch a Leafs forward dominate.
 
Dangles McGavin said:
I still really want Monahan.

Mackinnon or Monahan would be my dream pick. I'd think that they'd both go back down to Juniors again next year and will make team Canada.

Would be fun to watch a Leafs forward dominate.
Click to expand...

Historically, 1st overall picks do not go back to Juniors. I think Mackinnon would have the talent required to slide into the top 6 or 9 on our team in a sheltered role. Much like Boston did with Seguin.

Monahan might be better served back in Junior though to finely tune his offensive game. But, who knows. With his complete game he could make it in 2013 as well.
 
For once i want to see our guys play in these tournaments as premiere guys.

It's great for their confidence and development.

I sure hope they let Reilly play in this tournament again next year, even if they send him from the AHL.

I hope for Mackinnon, but Monahan wont be a bad consolation. Drouin looks great, but the number 1 center plays a big factor.
 
dannyboy8920 said:
For once i want to see our guys play in these tournaments as premiere guys.

It's great for their confidence and development.

I sure hope they let Reilly play in this tournament again next year, even if they send him from the AHL.

I hope for Mackinnon, but Monahan wont be a bad consolation. Drouin looks great, but the number 1 center plays a big factor.
Click to expand...

Rielly's unable to play in the A next year, so it'll probably all come down to whether he's still in juniors or the NHL. Should be an interesting case, if he makes the team it probably means that he's too valuable to give up for any extended period of the schedule, but if he's with Moose Jaw still, then you can pretty much guarantee he'll be there, barring any injury issues. I agree though, it would be nice to see him on the world stage again with another year of experience under his belt and in a better position to be counted on as a leader for Team Canada.
 
IBeL13f said:
Rielly's unable to play in the A next year, so it'll probably all come down to whether he's still in juniors or the NHL. Should be an interesting case, if he makes the team it probably means that he's too valuable to give up for any extended period of the schedule, but if he's with Moose Jaw still, then you can pretty much guarantee he'll be there, barring any injury issues. I agree though, it would be nice to see him on the world stage again with another year of experience under his belt and in a better position to be counted on as a leader for Team Canada.
Click to expand...

I hope next year he rips it up in the next year in the WJC if he is still in the juniors. Which is where I'd hope he hones his skills to the max. As well with this draft passing by I hope we have another player in that WJC roster.
 
Interactif said:
Probably no surprise but a New top 3 will be released by a scouting service very soon.

1-Jones
2-Mackinnon
3-Drouin
Click to expand...

I still have my doubts about Jones. Still wasn't all that impressed by his Canada game. Better than some earlier games but still not amazing by any means.

I'd say MacKinnon still last one, drouin at two and Jones three with lindholm at four, and barkov (who while less offensively potent, still had a better all around tourney than Jones so far IMO) at five
 
Hey guys, could you please tell me what kind of style do: Lindholm , barkov and Monahan play??


And can they all play center??

Thanks a lot :)
 
Interactif said:
Probably no surprise but a New top 3 will be released by a scouting service very soon.

1-Jones
2-Mackinnon
3-Drouin
Click to expand...

Good list. I am glad to see we, along with TSN, agree on Seth Jones. I guess his comments about him thinking the USA are the best team (after humilitating Canada) are also ignored now, now that he was right :sarcasm:

I would love to see the Leafs draft him, but I am starting to conspirically think that he ends up in an American market. Potential to be the best American d-man ever? Playing on a Canadian team?! No way! :(

BertCorbeau said:
What style of game does Lindholm play anyways? I haven't read up or watched any videos on him
Click to expand...

He's a nice consolation prize. Very good everything, but nothing elite. If he goes top 5, I can't see him doing better than his past Swedish counterparts. I don't see franchise\build-around player in him. He's just a very good piece to have.

TheFinnishKulemin said:
I still have my doubts about Jones. Still wasn't all that impressed by his Canada game. Better than some earlier games but still not amazing by any means.
Click to expand...

What game did you watch? Because the game that I saw had him dominating the Canadian top-line, the Canadian d-men afraid to jump into the rush, him still creating offensive chances, and a complete package of size, elite skating, and impact on the game. It's undeniable.

TheFinnishKulemin said:
I'd say MacKinnon still last one, drouin at two and Jones three with lindholm at four, and barkov (who while less offensively potent, still had a better all around tourney than Jones so far IMO) at five
Click to expand...

I have to ask, do you just have something against Seth Jones? Because this list is downright scary and shows clear symptoms of denial. TSN even says he is the clear #1 at this point.

alcanalz said:
Where? Mackinnon is still the clear #1, as has been said by many analysts.
Click to expand...

It was mentioned during the broadcast by their commentators. If you search on HF, you will see some other posters mentioning it as well.

Mackinnon was #1 before, but probably will still battle [and could upset Jones] when it is all over.
 
Last edited:
Epictetus said:
I have to ask, do you just have something against Seth Jones? Because this list is downright scary and shows clear symptoms of denial. TSN even says he is the clear #1 at this point.
Click to expand...
Where? Mackinnon is still the clear #1, as has been said by many analysts.
 
The Naz said:
A lot about him compares favourably to Backstrom. Older in the draft year, one of the best for his age in the SEL, playmaker with skill and shifty style. Small.
Click to expand...

I can see that as well.

But Lindholm bring a physical edge over Backstrom. He's a natural center, But he plays Wing for Brynas and has shown to be aggressive and effective fore checker.
 
Rare Jewel said:
I can see that as well.

But Lindholm bring a physical edge over Backstrom. He's a natural center, But he plays Wing for Brynas and has shown to be aggressive and effective fore checker.
Click to expand...

I like ... Kessel needs a centre like that, one reason why I reeeeaally want Mackinnon since he's similar in that he's an aggressive forechecker down low
 
alcanalz said:
Where? Mackinnon is still the clear #1, as has been said by many analysts.
Click to expand...

Which analysts?
Most lists had MacKinnon at #1, but seemed to suggest it was close between them. After the WJC ,would have to think its pretty even between them.

As much as I like MacKinnon, you can see why some scouts would be drooling over Jones. He has areas of his game that need improved, but he looks big and very mobile, with a lot of composure. Also, he looks very young in the face and I think he still has a bit of growing to do. Could end up being about 6'6" and 240lbs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom