Maybe I remember things different. I recall that Hyman signing with Edmonton was the worst kept secret in the league. Obviously everyone liked Hyman because come on it's hard not to. Fans liked the player but hated on Holland for overpaying on both AAV and length. Hyman never scored more than 41 points with Toronto and had some serious injury concerns. I dont even think even the most optimistic fans would have thought he would put up 60 points in 49 games.
Also maybe it's just me but when fans say "the AAV is fine but the length is too long" or "the length is fine but the AAV is too high" its beyond frustrating. You usually have to overpay UFAs and the price/term are correlated. It's the same type of fans that want to give up peanuts in a trade but get back a stud.