Wright, Slafkovsky, Cooley : Time to make that final decision

Who is your 1st overall pick?


  • Total voters
    883
Status
Not open for further replies.

HabsFather

Twitter: @HabsFather
Jul 12, 2006
565
335
Montreal Forum
www.getthepuckout.net
They can end up picking Wright while being high on both of those guys also, why wouldn’t they be on a top of the draft so close between the players?
I think it has more to do with putting the bait out there. They have intended on picking Wright and know Devils don't need a Center. So they bait that they like the big winger and are undecided abkut Wright in hopes Devils are like "heres a 3rd round pick dont pick the big winger" not saying it will happen but they at least tried.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Krett Bulak

Frank Drebin

Likes are suspended, sorry for inconvenience
Sponsor
Mar 9, 2004
35,599
23,321
Edmonton
I think it has more to do with putting the bait out there. They have intended on picking Wright and know Devils don't need a Center. So they bait that they like the big winger and are undecided abkut Wright in hopes Devils are like "heres a 3rd round pick dont pick the big winger" not saying it will happen but they at least tried.
Devils would never say "heres a third, don't pick the big winger". They would say, "heres a third, let us pick first"
 

MTL-rules

Registered User
Nov 17, 2006
9,705
2,473
Slaf is going to be an Anthony Mantha 2.0, big, fast and soft. Good but not great... Wright at worst a Ryan O'reilly... Pretty obvious choice.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sterling Archer

Mister Hab

Registered User
Nov 21, 2018
205
229
...we've needed Top 6 centre depth for around 25 years or so...
Absolutely (Wright, Suzuki, Dvorak, Evans, Poehling, Pitlick, Kidney....quality and quantity...finally!!).
We've been waiting DECADES for this opportunity.

I still can't believe there are still some Hab fans that don't think we urgently need to add another CENTER with star potential (Wright). This is our chance...we're so lucky to have the no.1 pick. A lot of us Hab fans were sweating and looking at the standings all season ("Pain for Shane").

We finally finished last in the standings (I really worried we would end up 5th or 6th or even 7th)....amazing! Still can't believe it. Still loving it.

We had to wait some more till May 10 (NHL lottery)...won the lottery (no.1 pick). Amazing!

Now we still have to wait till July 7...so happy we're almost there.
All this talk about Slaf or Cooley or Nemec for the no.1 pick is driving me crazy!!

The "Wright" pick for no.1 is a major no-brainer...Shane Wright.

July 7 we better be having a Shane Wright party or else I'll freak out.
 

Mister Hab

Registered User
Nov 21, 2018
205
229
Slaf is going to be an Anthony Mantha 2.0, big, fast and soft. Good but not great... Wright at worst a Ryan O'reilly... Pretty obvious choice.
Not a bad comparison. (And, maybe Mantha is faster than Slaf?).
Imo, Slaf may also end up another Puljujarvi or Kakko. All size and no-NHLer-Olympic hype.


Wright's ceiling: a star no.1 two-way/unselfish center (Patrice Bergeron, Suzuki++).

Wright's floor: a responsible/decent two-way no.2 center.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sterling Archer

Kaladin

Registered User
Nov 5, 2017
787
1,113
Absolutely (Wright, Suzuki, Dvorak, Evans, Poehling, Pitlick, Kidney....quality and quantity...finally!!).
We've been waiting DECADES for this opportunity.

I still can't believe there are still some Hab fans that don't think we urgently need to add another CENTER with star potential (Wright). This is our chance...we're so lucky to have the no.1 pick. A lot of us Hab fans were sweating and looking at the standings all season ("Pain for Shane").

We finally finished last in the standings (I really worried we would end up 5th or 6th or even 7th)....amazing! Still can't believe it. Still loving it.

We had to wait some more till May 10 (NHL lottery)...won the lottery (no.1 pick). Amazing!

Now we still have to wait till July 7...so happy we're almost there.
All this talk about Slaf or Cooley or Nemec for the no.1 pick is driving me crazy!!

The "Wright" pick for no.1 is a major no-brainer...Shane Wright.

July 7 we better be having a Shane Wright party or else I'll freak out.
I don't disagree that the Habs need a C with star potential. Cooley, incidentally happens to be a C with star potential too.

Your operating based on like months old information. This is no longer the Shane Wright draft exclusively. Wright may get more points but Cooley will be a gamer in the playoffs and Wright may disappear based on what I saw.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SlafySZN

Rob Sense

Registered User
Apr 26, 2015
2,550
3,189
I don't disagree that the Habs need a C with star potential. Cooley, incidentally happens to be a C with star potential too.

Your operating based on like months old information. This is no longer the Shane Wright draft exclusively. Wright may get more points but Cooley will be a gamer in the playoffs and Wright may disappear based on what I saw.
How can this information be old? None of these prospects have played a game in many weeks. Rising and falling of a player's stock is simply driven by so-called experts who want their audience to read their click-bait sites. All about creating discussion and hype. Wright is going 1OA otherwise Montreal is taking a huge risk.
 

26Mats

Registered User
Jun 23, 2018
33,379
25,771
Offhand I think it was 39 points in the first 33 games followed by 55 in 30

Ok so it was just over the 1st half of the season that wasn't as productive, versus the 2nd half of the season that he was very productive.

is there a single thread where people post who they want to pick? Will be interesting to see later haha

This is it.

Are the results of the poll public?

Based on all the hearsay, I'd take Wright. But I don't take my analysis seriously because I haven't done the research.
 

Kaladin

Registered User
Nov 5, 2017
787
1,113
How can this information be old? None of these prospects have played a game in many weeks. Rising and falling of a player's stock is simply driven by so-called experts who want their audience to read their click-bait sites. All about creating discussion and hype. Wright is going 1OA otherwise Montreal is taking a huge risk.
Taking Wright could be the risk is the point. If he ended up a second line 60 point C that doesn’t really drive play in the playoffs then that’s a waste of a 1st overall.

Personally, I think Cooley is unlikely to bust and has a decent floor too with higher upside and a more complementary style too Suzuki. Not everyone agrees but at the very least it’s a debate at this point between Wright, Cooley and Slaf.

Calling bob McKenzie’s list a “click bait site” is kinda rich though lol. Can we keep the conspiracy theories out of this?
 

Rob Sense

Registered User
Apr 26, 2015
2,550
3,189
Taking Wright could be the risk is the point. If he ended up a second line 60 point C that doesn’t really drive play in the playoffs then that’s a waste of a 1st overall.

Personally, I think Cooley is unlikely to bust and has a decent floor too with higher upside and a more complementary style too Suzuki. Not everyone agrees but at the very least it’s a debate at this point between Wright, Cooley and Slaf.

Calling bob McKenzie’s list a “click bait site” is kinda rich though lol. Can we keep the conspiracy theories out of this?
all this magic thinking about which 18 year old is going to be a 2C or not a bust is all hot air. Wright is going 1OA. And where did i call McKenzie click-bait? Please stop making up stuff and putting words in my mouth.
 

sheed36

Registered User
Jan 8, 2005
47,685
36,379
No Man's Land
Ok so it was just over the 1st half of the season that wasn't as productive, versus the 2nd half of the season that he was very productive.



This is it.

Are the results of the poll public?

Based on all the hearsay, I'd take Wright. But I don't take my analysis seriously because I haven't done the research.
The poll results above are public to me. Just click on the vote totals for each player and it'll show who voted for them.
 

Kaladin

Registered User
Nov 5, 2017
787
1,113
all this magic thinking about which 18 year old is going to be a 2C or not a bust is all hot air. Wright is going 1OA. And where did i call McKenzie click-bait? Please stop making up stuff and putting words in my mouth.
You said rising and falling of a players stock is all hot air and driven by authors wanting clickbait. Given McKenzie is the most prominent author who pegged Wright at second overall, contradicting your statement of fact that Wright is going 1OA. I assume you are including him in this criticism. If this is not a fair assumption, I apologize.

I agree with your comment no one really knows who will bust or will do well after the draft.
 

HuGort

Registered User
Jun 15, 2012
21,672
10,656
Nova Scotia
I haven't seen one but have RDS or some other media done a poll asking who the Habs should pick 1st overall? Be curious to see the results outside of HF.
I think Slaf scoring all his points against countries like Italy or France and none against top teams cooled many fans. Especially after being burnt before on prospects who played well in small sample size. Ie. Kostitsyn, Drouin.
 

26Mats

Registered User
Jun 23, 2018
33,379
25,771
Absolutely (Wright, Suzuki, Dvorak, Evans, Poehling, Pitlick, Kidney....quality and quantity...finally!!).
We've been waiting DECADES for this opportunity.

I still can't believe there are still some Hab fans that don't think we urgently need to add another CENTER with star potential (Wright). This is our chance...we're so lucky to have the no.1 pick. A lot of us Hab fans were sweating and looking at the standings all season ("Pain for Shane").

We finally finished last in the standings (I really worried we would end up 5th or 6th or even 7th)....amazing! Still can't believe it. Still loving it.

We had to wait some more till May 10 (NHL lottery)...won the lottery (no.1 pick). Amazing!

Now we still have to wait till July 7...so happy we're almost there.
All this talk about Slaf or Cooley or Nemec for the no.1 pick is driving me crazy!!

The "Wright" pick for no.1 is a major no-brainer...Shane Wright.

July 7 we better be having a Shane Wright party or else I'll freak out.


We've added "centers" in the past, with so-called "star potential (Drouin, Kotkaniemi).

The question isn't whether we need a center with star potential or whether Suzuki-Dvorak-Evans-Poehling is just fine and dany.

The question is: how good is Shane Wright??? Just as the question should have been, how good are Drouin and Kotkaniemi, not what need do we have that they can potentially address.

That's the question that all the scouts are asking themselves. If your analysis has answered that question for yourself. Great for you. Apparently the scouts who do this for a living are more divided.

The only opinion I care about is the one we'll hear from our scouts on July 7th. Not because I trust them more. It's a new bunch with no track record. Things are so up in the air, all we can do is hope they know what they're doing - and hope we have more lottery picks over the next few years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kaladin

Rob Sense

Registered User
Apr 26, 2015
2,550
3,189
You said rising and falling of a players stock is all hot air and driven by authors wanting clickbait. Given McKenzie is the most prominent author who pegged Wright at second overall, contradicting your statement of fact that Wright is going 1OA. I assume you are including him in this criticism. If this is not a fair assumption, I apologize.

I agree with your comment no one really knows who will bust or will do well after the draft.
Not a fait assumption. I was referring to both the click bait rumor sites and the armchair experts who come out of woodwork to post here.
 

Kaladin

Registered User
Nov 5, 2017
787
1,113
Not a fait assumption. I was referring to both the click bait rumor sites and the armchair experts who come out of woodwork to post here.
I mean you’ve complimented Wright a lot last few weeks. Would you consider yourself an armchair expert too?
 

Tyson

Registered User
Mar 1, 2007
50,075
72,651
Texas
Well I have read and read and researched and researched and my amateur opinion is that Shane Wright needs to be the pick.

While Slafkovsky has shown some intriguing things I still can't get past the 10 points in 31 Liga games.

Wright started off slowly and underwhelmed in the playoffs but he did average 1.63 PPG from December on.

It also helps that Wright is a center who appears physically very mature.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad