Proposal: Win nyr

[jay from jersey]

win gets
Mats zucarello
brady skjei

nYR gets
trouba
Lowry


trouba wants out. His skillset has been discussed to death NYR needs a 1 RD. He has a lot of potential. Lowry gives them a 4th center for the future as well.

win gets zuc who can play both wings, cost controlled, 60+pts.
skjei who is dubbed mini McD by many. Skates like the wind,big,talented. His offense is a ?. he will be a top 4 D in the NHL no doubt. If his offense game rounds out he is a McDonuagh clone. If not he is more brett hedican. 1 month younger then trouba

Click to read more...

 

[CapSpace]

NYR give to much for Trouba.

 

[jay from jersey]

yea

NYR give to much for Trouba.

but lowry is not chopped liver. he could be a good 4th line center in the years to come. see my reasoning is zuc or skjei by themselves is not enough for trouba, but a package of them both is too much. there needs to be another player coming back. I figure lowry or a prospect like lemuiex would be closer value

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

win gets
Mats zucarello
brady skjei

nYR gets
trouba
Lowry


trouba wants out. His skillset has been discussed to death NYR needs a 1 RD. He has a lot of potential. Lowry gives them a 4th center for the future as well.

win gets zuc who can play both wings, cost controlled, 60+pts.
skjei who is dubbed mini McD by many. Skates like the wind,big,talented. His offense is a ?. he will be a top 4 D in the NHL no doubt. If his offense game rounds out he is a McDonuagh clone. If not he is more brett hedican. 1 month younger then trouba

Winnipeg doesn't need more Forwards, They're looking for a top 4 LHD that can take Trouba's spot and sorry that's not Skjei.

 

[Maukkis]

McDonagh or bust.

 

[KirkOut]

Wouldn't do that if I was Winnipeg.

 

[Matt Rentfree]

McDonagh or bust.

Makes no sense for the Rangers to do that. Just switches our problem from the right side to the left. We're not good trade partners.

 

[bernmeister]

McDonagh or bust.

Basically this, with adds on both sides.

 

[bernmeister]

Makes no sense for the Rangers to do that. Just switches our problem from the right side to the left. We're not good trade partners.

Respectfully disagree.
We have better upcoming on our left, more quickly --- Skjei, Graves
we do not have similar at RD
idea is to acquire RD w/out sacrificing THESE LDs, esp since exp draft is coming up

This assumes no one is thinking outside the box.

Whether Wini or otherwise, we should take advantage of ability to retain salary, do so drastically on Stepan AND Staal, as a package, and move them both.
{obviously, that is not necessarily the whole package.
EG
if Jets
Step at 4, Staal at 3 and Raanta (1.0 x2)
for
Trouba (RFA, but will cost at least 6 min on long term deal)
Burmistrov 1.55 expiring
and Pavelec 3.9 expiring

Is Burmi a happy camper? enough to extend reasonably?
if not, move as above, recover $ in net w/2 year stop gap
Staal no longer in AV, ok asset or better at 3, and Stepan, if you don't want as long term replacement for Burmi, can move readily at 4.

I consider that fair.
Jets get the better deal in exch for taking on Staal's NMC

If you want something to hedge vs staal on top of the discount, I would be willing to discuss conditional picks, or just give you G prospect Halverson.}

 

[UAGoalieGuy]

Trouba doesnt net you McD.

 

[itsPLkielbasa]

Trouba doesnt net you McD.

This. Especially since he wants out if they won't let him play his side.
We don't really make good trade partners.

Always too far off on proposals from both sides.

 

[sully1410]

win gets
Mats zucarello
brady skjei

nYR gets
trouba
Lowry


trouba wants out. His skillset has been discussed to death NYR needs a 1 RD. He has a lot of potential. Lowry gives them a 4th center for the future as well.

win gets zuc who can play both wings, cost controlled, 60+pts.
skjei who is dubbed mini McD by many. Skates like the wind,big,talented. His offense is a ?. he will be a top 4 D in the NHL no doubt. If his offense game rounds out he is a McDonuagh clone. If not he is more brett hedican. 1 month younger then trouba

Nope. We would want McDonagh.

Don't need wingers and want comparable D to Trouba.

 

[StevenB]

but lowry is not chopped liver. he could be a good 4th line center in the years to come. see my reasoning is zuc or skjei by themselves is not enough for trouba, but a package of them both is too much. there needs to be another player coming back. I figure lowry or a prospect like lemuiex would be closer value

>Can play on the fourth line
>isn't chopped liver

Pick one

Maybe if dano goes back the other way will NY give both Zuc and Skjei. Winnipeg, the longer you drag this one, the less you'll get for Trouba. You're not going to get full value for Trouba

 

[Jeti]

Zucc is worth more to NYR than the Jets.

Has to be McD

 

[Gump Hasek]

Woefully inadequate Jersey Jay offer #1: Jets don't need any more smalls; PASS


Bernmeister special #1: Jets don't need any old Staals; PASS

 

[UAGoalieGuy]

Miller and Skjei for Trouba is a fair offer.

 

[Gump Hasek]

Miller and Skjei for Trouba is a fair offer.

Fair to you, perhaps.

Jets don't need any forwards, nor any prospect D in exchange for Trouba for that matter; PASS

 

[Irishguy42]

If Winnipeg wants McDonagh, they're going to need to give way more than Trouba.

 

[Gump Hasek]

If Winnipeg wants McDonagh, they're going to need to give way more than Trouba.

Nah.

Winnipeg isn't the one asking here. The price for Trouba is McD.

Don't like the price? No sale.

 

[Irishguy42]

Nah.

Winnipeg isn't the one asking here. The price for Trouba is McD.

Don't like the price? No sale.

Gorton hangs up laughing at Chevy.

That's might be how it works in your mind, but it's likely not.

 

[Gump Hasek]

Gorton hangs up laughing at Chevy.

That's might be how it works in your mind, but it's likely not.

Still no sale.

Oh well. Thanks for calling.

 

[Snowman]

Gorton hangs up laughing at Chevy

As long as he doesn't call back, we're good.

 

[Hunter368]

win gets
Mats zucarello
brady skjei

nYR gets
trouba
Lowry


trouba wants out. His skillset has been discussed to death NYR needs a 1 RD. He has a lot of potential. Lowry gives them a 4th center for the future as well.

win gets zuc who can play both wings, cost controlled, 60+pts.
skjei who is dubbed mini McD by many. Skates like the wind,big,talented. His offense is a ?. he will be a top 4 D in the NHL no doubt. If his offense game rounds out he is a McDonuagh clone. If not he is more brett hedican. 1 month younger then trouba

No thx, no interest or need in Mats. Pass

Only thing Rangers have of interest to the Jets is McDonagh.

 

[RangerGuru]

Pass on the OP, Zucc+Skjei is pretty steep

Also, hard pass on McDonagh, he's the only reliable guy we have on D

Have fun with the headache of Trouba - not good trade partners here

 

[Alluckks]

WPG fans say they want a Defenseman comparable to Trouba that plays the left side. Then they cite McDonagh. Doesn't make sense. They are not comparable. McDonagh is what Trouba hopes to be in a few years.