who is your teams worst goalie in the last decades

[FrozenJagrt]

Perhaps not statistically the worst, but very few Leafs goalies have caused me as much stress as Vesa Toskala. I'll admit some of that stress came from the fact that there was a good chunk of Leafs nation that loved him at first.

 

[Jacob582]

Oh boy for the Sabres-

Don’t think Houser counts, and Dell got banished to the AHL after he checked a dude and got suspended. Our goalies have been so bad one of ‘em forgot basic goalie rules, that’s somethin. Carter Hutton could only see outta one eye or had a brain worm or somethin. Chad Johnson played for us, ochocinco himself. Idk, I go Dell, f*** that dude, dont care if he doesn’t totally hit criteria.

I was either thinking Hutton or Jonas Johansson, but totally forgot about Dell.

 

[Voight]

name anybody who played at least a full season on your team.

for the capitals i name jose theodore, i remember he had a tendency to let in the first shot every second game... also fans called him jose threeormore

​

There's no scraps in my scrapbook.

 

[Soundgarden]

We just traded him! Wedgewood didn't seem AHL caliber let alone NHL worthy.

 

[Alexander the Gr8]

For the Caps, it’s without a doubt Ilya Samsonov AKA Swimming Sammy.

Completely clueless at times and unable to hold on to his stick. It got so bad at one point that I thought they should consider taping his stick to his hand.

 

[Porter Stoutheart]

We just traded him! Wedgewood didn't seem AHL caliber let alone NHL worthy.

I came here to say Wedgewood.

But he doesn't actually meet the criteria, since he was here such a short time. Was soooo brutal in pre-season and early season, however, that he really stands out.

I honestly thought David Rittich looked so bad, like fundamentally flawed and immobile, that he might have been my next pick who actually met the criteria? But LA sure seems to be getting a different version of him?

 

[Soundgarden]

I came here to say Wedgewood.

But he doesn't actually meet the criteria, since he was here such a short time. Was soooo brutal in pre-season and early season, however, that he really stands out.

I honestly thought David Rittich looked so bad, like fundamentally flawed and immobile, that he might have been my next pick who actually met the criteria? But LA sure seems to be getting a different version of him?

Oh man, I forgot all about Rittich.

 

[CharasLazyWrister]

Perhaps not statistically the worst, but very few Leafs goalies have caused me as much stress as Vesa Toskala. I'll admit some of that stress came from the fact that there was a good chunk of Leafs nation that loved him at first.

I felt like Toskala let in everything and anything during his era with the Leafs. As a bruins fan, I did not understand why so many Leafs fans seem to let him off the hook. I know the team in front of him was lackluster but the guy was a sieve if there ever was one.

 

[GrkFlyersFan]

Keeping it to actual full-time starters or backups? I want to say Antero Niittymaki, but from the last decade? This isn't accurate to his on the ice play, but the spiritual answer here is 79. Could also be Michal Neuvirth and his groin, but when he actually played he wasn't that bad. Cal Petersen was never full-time really, but he was awful. We did have a full season of Felix Sandstrom as our backup, but even he wasn't as bad. I'll stick with 79 because f him!

 

[cjm502]

Out of guys that were expected to actually be NHL goalies, Greiss, Hellberg. Husso looks like he is trying to get on their level. Jimmy Howards last season was abysmal but so was the entire team and Jimmy was actually a decent goalie for most of his career. Jared Coreau was always pretty good with the Griffins but was given 21 NHL games over 3 years and he blew it every chance he got, but he wasn't really brought up with expectations of being a full time NHL guy.

 

[Oddbob]

Tim Cheveldae. Guy has been completely invisible for at least 20 years.

 

[Mitch nylander]

Jonas Enroth

 

[lawrence]

Dan Cloutier

 

[Carbooja]

Steve Mason for the win.

 

[TheBeard]

Weirdly, I'd say Martin Jones post - 2018-19, but it's so hard to determine considering how bad the Sharks have been. If I have to go entire body of work I will go Kappa Khakonen.

 

[hirawl]

I name Samsonov for three franchises.

 

[HabzSauce]

Tough call between Michael Leighton and Scott Darling.

But Spencer Martin is currently giving both of them a run for their money with his sick .846 after 9 games.

Spencer Martin is maybe worst goalie I've seen in long time

 

[PWiz30]

There have been many contenders for the post-Marty Devils but I'd probably have to go with Jon Gillies. Very good college goalie, but not an NHL goalie.

 

[ZachaFlockaFlame]

There have been many contenders for the post-Marty Devils but I'd probably have to go with Jon Gillies. Very good college goalie, but not an NHL goalie.

Came here to say the same thing lol

 

[parrotdude]

Let's see...just how many former/current Kings goalies are on this list...

In order of the posts:
Bernier (Leafs)
Campbell (Leafs and Oilers)
Scrivens (Oilers)
Labarbara (Oilers)
Rittich
Dan Cloutier (Vancouver)
Martin Jones (San Jose)

...and nobody mentioned the King's worst recent goalie, Cal Petersen, yet.

 

[VivaLasVegas]

For the Caps, it’s without a doubt Ilya Samsonov AKA Swimming Sammy.

Completely clueless at times and unable to hold on to his stick. It got so bad at one point that I thought they should consider taping his stick to his hand.

Yeah, yeah, but Samsonov made this fantastic play on Saturday night!

 

[GrkFlyersFan]

Let's see...just how many former/current Kings goalies are on this list...

In order of the posts:
Bernier (Leafs)
Campbell (Leafs and Oilers)
Scrivens (Oilers)
Labarbara (Oilers)
Rittich
Dan Cloutier (Vancouver)
Martin Jones (San Jose)

...and nobody mentioned the King's worst recent goalie, Cal Petersen, yet.

I did

 

[Nogatco Rd]

For Washington, I'd like to go with Samsonov

He's my Capitals pick

That was my first thought but IMO Kuemper was worse

Yeah, yeah, but Samsonov made this fantastic play on Saturday night!

Lmao didn’t want to be outdone by Lindgren’s own goal

 

[TBF1972]

finally a win for the devils!

jon gillies

ainec

 

[BlueSeal]

For the Blues? Lalime.