Not knocking Stutzle, but this all seems like a classic case of being bored of having a definitive 1-2 in the draft so Byfield is now being nitpicked to death.
Hands and speed like this on a guy that will wind up playing at 225-230 pounds is ridiculous. This type of skill set works in the "New" NHL and the old NHL.
I once again will say that I'm just a limited viewings via YouTube scout, but Byfield is checking all of the boxes except I'm not seeing him crushing guys on the forecheck. I know a lot of players can do the between the legs shot, but a guy his size doing it so close to the front of the net and in an international competition is pretty silly. The one clip where he knocks the puck forward at the blueline and then does a full 360 spin while engaged with a defender is absolutely insane when you factor in his size. The agility is ridiculous and I think the physical play--at least leaning on guys--will eventually come when he gets his man strength.
A guy like Vilardi doesn't have the skating of Byfield so he relied on the heavy play on the cycle and really used his size because he had to. Byfield's skating allows him to play like a much smaller player but you do see him use his size in some of the clips with these clips showing that he has the potential to control play down low.
I agree with you on another point as well in that teams should be built to win 7-game series, not to win the President's Trophy.
If Vilardi can stay healthy and they take Byfield, you could eventually have teams contending with the size/speed combo of QB, the heavy puck-control game of Vilardi and then what I expect to be the tenacity of Turcotte. That would be real tough to handle over the course of a seven game series.
Then you have Arty who is still my favorite prospect. It can't be overlooked that moving up in this draft to #2 should be a boost to AK's development and odds of making it. Be it Byfield or Stutzle, one of these guys should be setting up AK with some great scoring opportunities. The power play should be much improved.