I love Kopitar. He might actually be my #1 all-time Kings over the course of being a fan since 1975. But he's not a traditional leader (William Wallace follow me into battle) type personality. Brown is and he's a heart & soul type. Quick has that personality, but of course he's your goalie. Captain isn't simply your best player or points leader. It's more than that. The Brown demotion was an embarrassment. I could understand it if there was a guy ready to take the reigns and be that leader. But we had nobody (except for maybe Quick). DD was too young at the time and he's still just not mature enough (among other issues.
I'd rather a guy like Justin Williams be my Captain or than Kopitar. Mike Richards without the drugs would have been a good C.
No Kings' speeches for Dustin Brown
"They say actions speak louder than words; and he's yelling his leadership on the ice with the way he plays," said teammate Dustin Penner, who described Brown as a "relentless and tireless worker and a
quiet leader."
The "quiet leader" saluted by other 2003 draft greats; magic tricks, game-changing hits and accountability - LA Kings Insider
Jeff Carter, on reconnecting with Brown when joining the team in 2012:
You grow up getting into the league at 18, you get married and have kids. Guys change a lot. Brownie, when I came in, he was still a quiet guy, but he was that
quiet leader and you know when he said something in the room, everybody listened.
Dustin Brown has been delivering the big hits longer than any other player in Kings history
“He was so quiet in the room,” Robitaille said. “He would just sit quietly, but you could see him play like a tank.
“I still think he’s a shy guy. But it’s the way he played that’s the reason that he became a captain, and then he really took it upon himself to be a great leader. He went out of his way to learn to express himself. He’s always been a great
quiet leader.”
Dustin Brown endures as one of the NHL’s most criticized captains
“In the room, I’m
pretty quiet. I’m getting myself ready in-between periods. My vocal leadership is more in-game, on the bench. There’s more ups and down on the bench. It’s about keeping the guys upbeat,” said Brown.
--------------
I don't see how an argument can be made that Brown is a traditional leader and Kopitar is not, when the consensus around the club has always been that Brown let his play do the talking, which by my book would be classified as nontraditional.
Furthermore, Brown was removed as captain because he had 3 consecutive sub-30 point seasons (ignoring the preceding shortened 2013 season). Now I'm not really a "pressure of the captaincy" guy and certainly recognize that multiple factors, including the departure of Sutter and change in system, likely were contributors, but Brown had a clear offensive resurgence after the C was removed from his chest.
I believe one large contributor to this was the gradual change in officiating and rules, particularly in regards to hits to the head, and its effect on Brown's style of play. Referee's became very reactive to the big hits and on several instances Brown had been heavily penalized for hits that, upon review, followed the letter of the law. Off the top of my head I can think of the hit on Miettinen in 2010 in which he delivered an open ice shoulder-to-shoulder hit and was thrown out of the game for a headshot. DPS rescinded the match penalty the next day and called it a legal hit. Also the infamous hurtl of Hertl in 2013 in which he was also tossed but DPS did not impose any supplemental discipline for the collision. Brown expressed his frustration because he was following the rules, but still being tossed from games. He recognized that, as captain, he can't be getting tossed from games and struggled to remain effective while worrying about the ref's making the wrong call again.
Switching the captaincy to Kopitar was the right move, it allowed Brown to focus on playing his game. 147 points in 219 games the last 3 seasons vs 82 points in 243 games the last 3 seasons he was captain.