by what metric was he better then Matthews since Matthews had the same PPG in only his 2nd season in the league in 17/18? then same again in 18.19. why would anyone thought he wasn't going to be better then Tavares from year one.
I mean if you look league wide over Tavares first 5 years the Leafs are 8 goals behind first for the most goals by the team, in order for Tavares to produce top 10 numbers the team would have had to score about 50 more goals, 40 more then any other team is that realistic? when were 3rd and 8 behind the top team? scoring effects matter, role on the team matter, role on a PP matters, he was always the 2nd line center(Tavares)
Tavares is paying the only role he can get pts at.
He has no puck skills or vision to run a PP, no elite shot to be a goal scorer
Front of the net got him 40 pts on the PP in 2023
He cant generate chances for his wingers. We thought he would be a play driving center who could give 50+ assists and 40+ goals at minimum
He cant creat looks, struggles to finish and is reliant in linemates
This year he had 65 pts as he wasnt able to keep up on the PP or at 5v5 with marner or nylander.
28 - 32 year seasons should still be part of your prime.
Gilmour, Sundin were still elite players during their late 20s to mid 30s
Tavares hasnt been elite except for 2019
He was very good in 2020 and 2021
But since then his play and production has fallen off as scoring has gone up, and he cant be relied on to create offense for his wingers