No Name The Nameless
Registered User
JC was a lottery pick who immediately entered the NHL. Despite his youth he has had two pretty good seasons, one very good season and one great season. He absolutely did replicate his good season and has improved each year.He's had one good season, and hasn't been able to replicate it. He's not good defensively right now, and if you are known for offense you need to be a lot better. He put up 8 points in his last 5 games which brought him up to #69 in points for defensemen. I mean, until a few days ago he had the same amount of points as Durzi, who has played fewer games. #1 guys known for offense are way above that level.
If you take his average points per game and extrapolate that he's a 34 point per season defenseman. He rarely plays against the other teams best players, and with those deployments he's still the worst minus on his team by a large margin. He's a -23 while the next worse is a -6. Yeah, that stat ain't perfect but #1 Defense guys generally don't have those kinds of numbers this far into their careers. With his easy deployments, you would expect his possession metrics to be solid, but they aren't.
He's not a terrible defenseman by any means, but he's not a #1. He's eerily similar to Jack Johnson for me. Good offense, subpar defense. Despite good size only throws the occasional hit. Has a penchant for goals going in while he's on the ice. He's a solid #2, and a great #3. I'm fine with a 1st and a solid prospect for the guy, but not one of our blue-chippers.
He hasn’t even entered his prime as a defenseman so to take the beginning of this year and judge him for it is judging a proven abnomormality.
Also, he didn’t all of a sudden forget how to defend. You are selling a Norris caliber player short without giving any benefit of doubt.