What does Marchand need to be 1st ballot HHOFer?

GMR

Registered User
Jul 27, 2013
6,743
5,790
Parts Unknown
He's never even been top 10


One of the Sedin's won a Pearson, but Marchand is somehow more difficult to play against and a better two way threat? Sounds like the players they played against felt otherwise
The Sedins were never great defensively and were not physical. Yes, they were easier to play against than a scrappy player like Marchand who could score and get under opponents' skin. They weren't the most clutch players to be exact.

But hey, they won a trophy one season just like Jamie Benn and Corey Perry.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nbwingsfan

nbwingsfan

Registered User
Dec 13, 2009
22,250
16,425
Can't believe 950 points, 1 cup, one 100 point season, and no individual awards of any kind gets you into the hall these days ...

Marchand to me is in the hall of very very good right alongside Toews and Backstrom
1. He won’t finish with 950, he’ll be over 1000

2. He has 3 gold medals, maybe 4

3. Captain of an original 6 team

You can argue how much the last two matter, but undoubtedly it matters to who chooses.

It’s not the NHL HoF
 

nbwingsfan

Registered User
Dec 13, 2009
22,250
16,425
He's never even been top 10


One of the Sedin's won a Pearson, but Marchand is somehow more difficult to play against and a better two way threat? Sounds like the players they played against felt otherwise
Marchand was 3rd in PPG over like a 4 years stretch while being a two way force and arguably the best PK player in the league…

Not top 10 :laugh:
 

22Brad Park

Registered User
Nov 23, 2008
47,722
26,902
Calgary AB
Toews has a conn smythe, selke, 2 Olympic gold medals, a few junior championships, and 3 cups. Don’t think he really compares that well to brad or even backstrom.

Well it’s not a hall of how good you are. It’s a hall of fame. Individual awards matter quite a bit.

Marchand does have a lot going for him anyway. I think he might get in eventually but I don’t see him as a first year type of lock.
He has over 400 goals with good chance at 1000 pts plus a Cup and one of best shorthanded players in history.
 
  • Love
Reactions: Mike C

Jumptheshark

Rebooting myself
Oct 12, 2003
100,923
14,806
Somewhere on Uranus
For those mentioning the sedins?

Their trophy case

Art ross
Clancy
Lindley

The other one?
Art ross
Hart memorial
2 clancey award


Marchand?
Trophy case empty

Until they won awards? I called them the sisters this got me banned from the f***s board

To compare them to marchand? Is an insult to the twins
 

NVious

Registered User
Dec 20, 2022
1,549
3,473
You know nothing about hockey.Go watch ringette.
Yeah you're right:
1 cup and 1 100 point season>>>>>>>>>1 cup, 1 conn, 2 vezinas

Congrats to the scumbag rat on being a part of NHL history and losing after being up 3-0 in a series....IN THE FINALS.

Marchand should campaign for Thomas because if he didn't will them to that cup, he'd have NOTHING (except his God tier 100 point season LMAO)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: PB37

Ghost of Murph

Registered User
Dec 23, 2023
1,177
1,923
Mentioning character and sportsmanship as reasons Marchand should not get into the HHOF is odd considering who is already in the HHOF. Marchand is a saint compared to some of those players.

Peak Marchand was not only an elite scorer as others have pointed out with stats, but his defensive stats when playing on the same line as Bergeron were filthy during those years. Bergeron/Marchand was one of the elite duos of this century. Much like Bergeron, when you look beyond the simple stats you see a very elite complete player. But, I know, he licked someone so boo hoo.
 

GMR

Registered User
Jul 27, 2013
6,743
5,790
Parts Unknown
For those mentioning the sedins?

Their trophy case

Art ross
Clancy
Lindley

The other one?
Art ross
Hart memorial
2 clancey award


Marchand?
Trophy case empty

Until they won awards? I called them the sisters this got me banned from the f***s board

To compare them to marchand? Is an insult to the twins
Yes, how dare we insult the great Sedins.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Mike C

Sota Popinski

Registered Boozer
Sponsor
Apr 26, 2017
2,446
1,578
Minneapolis
The Sedins were never great defensively and were not physical. Yes, they were easier to play against than a scrappy player like Marchand who could score and get under opponents' skin. They weren't the most clutch players to be exact.

But hey, they won a trophy one season just like Jamie Benn and Corey Perry.
And Marchand won no trophies any season like Raffi Torres and Cal Clutterbuck
 

PB37

Mr Selke
Oct 1, 2002
26,270
22,002
Maine
For those mentioning the sedins?

Their trophy case

Art ross
Clancy
Lindley

The other one?
Art ross
Hart memorial
2 clancey award


Marchand?
Trophy case empty

Until they won awards? I called them the sisters this got me banned from the f***s board

To compare them to marchand? Is an insult to the twins
marchand-brad-marchand.gif
 

Score08

Registered User
Apr 6, 2017
4,914
5,143
Not only is he getting in but Jack Edwards will MC the event just to piss off the candy ass babies on hf boards .
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad