Proposal: Van/NYI: Miller/Hoglander/Rathbone

[SI]

49% that's better?

Pettersson is playing down the line-up right now, thankfully we have a top 10 scorer in the league to carry the slack.

It’s better than 41%.

And GREAT for you To have a top 10 scorer, then keep Miller and pay 8 or 9 m in a year... or did you just throw up in your mouth knowing you’ll have to pay him that much to keep him and also lose your captain in the process.

We love our guy And we’ll keep him happily, but continue to measure PPG over winning hockey (albeit not So much this year for Isles, but 13 GM road trip and COvid outbreak and forced to play games Will impact a teams record).

 

[Tables of Stats]

It’s better than 41%.

And GREAT for you To have a top 10 scorer, then keep Miller and pay 8 or 9 m in a year... or did you just throw up in your mouth knowing you’ll have to pay him that much to keep him and also lose your captain in the process.

We love our guy And we’ll keep him happily, but continue to measure PPG over winning hockey (albeit not So much this year for Isles, but 13 GM road trip and COvid outbreak and forced to play games Will impact a teams record).

I didn't start the thread, my dude. It's just funny that posters value Barzal over a glue player like Miller.

 

[SI]

I didn't start the thread, my dude. It's just funny that posters value Barzal over a glue player like Miller.

neither did I.

And f*** yeah - Barzal should be valued more.


It’s a Canuck fan making a shit proposal for our guy. And the fact that this proposal has been made is proof that so does your fan base.

then resign your glue guy - dude

 

[jackjohnson]

Miller and Boeser for Barzal and Dobson?
That would also work and be preferable in my opinion.

Miller AND Boeser? Are you serious? Why do the Canycks trade their 2 1st liners and one that is 13th in NHL scoring? Are they rebuilding? There is no way Barzal can replace their offense

 

[jackjohnson]

What are the Islanders receiving to make this worth giving up both Barzal and Dobson? This package just isn’t it. Let’s do this properly, replace the whole Vancouver side and upgrade all 3 options. After that, we may have a start.

How about Vancouver keep all their pieces and once they are scoring goals by the boatload, we will revisit this and see if your opinion will change.

 

[jackjohnson]

You think Miller is a top line center and that NYI should trade their far superior actual top line center for him? That's funny

Miller is a top line forward. You cant argue with that he is 13th in NHL scoring. Not sure why some posters here think Miller is some 3rd line scrub. Its ridiculous.

 

[jackjohnson]

What is the reverse in terms of trades for both teams?
VAN: EP40, Hughes
For
NYI: Nelson, Wilde, Wahlstrom

Take out Hughes because Hughes is like on a different stratosphere compared to Dobson. In Fact I probably would not trade Hughes for Barzal and Dobson combined

 

[Buresflyingelbow]

Miller AND Boeser? Are you serious? Why do the Canycks trade their 2 1st liners and one that is 13th in NHL scoring? Are they rebuilding? There is no way Barzal can replace their offense

That’s more to open up salary cap going forward. Value Canucks don’t come out on top. Balance of the roster is what we need.

 

[GhostfaceWu]

I wouldn’t even trade Hoglander for Barzal let alone Boeser. Why do the Canucks need a $7m center for their 3rd line?

Lol this is a terrible post how did people just gloss over it. I assume the 7 million dollar 3rs line center is Petersson right.

 

[Glorydays22]

what don't you get.....BRAZAL ISN'T AVAILABLE. Not interested in these players. Miller is nice but I rather build around Brazal