Defense isn't the Oilers problem anymore. They need a right hand PMD which Tanev is the complete opposite
That's quite the funny comment. He is not a #1 dman, but he is definitely a #2. He is one of the most elite defensive dmen in the league. He would solidify the defense for EDM to be an actual playoff team this year, and a legit cup contender next year.
Proposal: VAN/EDM Blockbuster
- Thread starter PatrikOverAuston
- Start date
mariolemieux66
Registered User
That's quite the funny comment. He is not a #1 dman, but he is definitely a #2. He is one of the most elite defensive dmen in the league. He would solidify the defense for EDM to be an actual playoff team this year, and a legit cup contender next year.
Tanev is not.
I don't think it's that bad of a proposal actually. Probably a little favored towards the Canucks, but I don't think it's that far off.
I difference in opinions here are probably based on how people value Eberle and Tanev. You're probably either hot or cold on either guy.
I difference in opinions here are probably based on how people value Eberle and Tanev. You're probably either hot or cold on either guy.
me2
Go ahead foot
I'd be fine with that. RNH for Tanev. Hansen and Sutter at the deadline for 1sts/prospects. I doubt Erberle lasts the rebuild with us, while he's more use to Edmonton now.
snipes
How cold? I’m ice cold.
- Dec 28, 2015
- 55,852
- 64,430
Tanev for Nuge straight up is probably pretty equal value.
However, in division trades like this are always risky. Tanev is a very good top pairing #2 defensive Dman, but if we're moving Nuge we would be looking more for an offensive PMD who can be our PP QB.
However, in division trades like this are always risky. Tanev is a very good top pairing #2 defensive Dman, but if we're moving Nuge we would be looking more for an offensive PMD who can be our PP QB.
McFlyingV
Registered User
If the Hall-Larsson trade never happened I'd be open to an RNH-Tanev type deal, but at this point we just can't give up RNH for another defensive D. We desperately need an offensive PP Dman, and I'm a little hesitant to trade RNH with Draisaitl struggling and Nuge looking great (with mediocre line mates).
snipes
How cold? I’m ice cold.
- Dec 28, 2015
- 55,852
- 64,430
Sure but Hall is good enough to move pass that. Also think that Tanev is the better defensive defensemen.
snipes
How cold? I’m ice cold.
- Dec 28, 2015
- 55,852
- 64,430
Tanev is also older, but yeah Tanev is an excellent defensive Dman. I was backing how good Tanev was in one of the Leafs/Canucks trade threads around Tanev.
I think Larsson is a little more physical which is a pleasant surprise. I would agree, right now Tanev is likely ahead of Larsson overall. Tanev is among the top defensive Dmen, a legit top pairing #2.
A big thing for Chia was the age of Larsson, he's 23 (24 in a week) and that's right around the age where Dmen start to come into their own. He's signed with 5 years left on his contract to a very favourable cap hit as well.
I think it comes down to need, we really need a playmaking RHD who can play big PP minutes. Value is fair in a Tanev for Nuge swap, but I don't think we could do it. Nuge also faces heavy defensive match ups and we would have a massive hole at centre with him gone.
JuniorNelson
Registered User
Burnt Biscuits
Registered User
- May 2, 2010
- 9,283
- 3,418
That's true, but the need for a shutdown d-man is greatly lessened with the addition of Larsson. We sacrificed value for something we were in dire need of, Tanev would be a valued addition, but he doesn't scratch our biggest itch which is a top 4 d who can QB the powerplay and who is good enough defensively to take a regular shift. Also RNH is very key to the Oilers being a good team we need a shutdown center who can contribute meaningful offense and having traded away Hall, Purcell, and Yakupov we are nowhere close to as skilled on the wings, Eberle used to be expendable trade bait, but I don't think that is the case at all anymore.
The OP's trade makes the Oilers worse and helps Van quite a bit who really need an influx of skill to their line-up.
Horse McHindu
They call me Horse.....
- Jun 21, 2014
- 9,668
- 2,650
Ryan Nugent-Hopkins ($6M)
Jordan Eberle ($6M)
Total- $12M
Chris Tanev (4.45M)
Brandon Sutter ($4.375M)
Jannik Hansen ($2.5M)
Total- $11.3M
I'm a Canucks fan.
I can honestly say that I'd take that deal in a heartbeat.
No idea why Edmonton would make that deal, but that's gold from a Canucks perspective.
ManofSteel55
Registered User
Doughty, Suter are for sure ahead of Tanev as well.
Hamonic, Stralman, Alzner, Muzzin, Larsson, McDonagh, Pietrangelo, are all in the discussion as well. Arguably others as well. Just because a few of them have better offense doesn't diminish the fact that they are just as solid (or more so) than Tanev defensively. And it doesn't mean Tanev isn't a stud, because he is.
Sempiternal
Registered User
- Jul 5, 2014
- 3,460
- 1,944
Addison Rae
Registered User
ryan suter better than chris tanev defensively? lmao dear lord
compare their results not their names
compare their results not their names
Sempiternal
Registered User
- Jul 5, 2014
- 3,460
- 1,944
TheGhost
Registered User
Tanev is a great defenseman, but not the type of player that Edmonton would or should consider moving RNH for. The biggest need the Oilers have is a right shot D-man that can run the PP, which Tanev doesn't do.
Regardless, Oilers coaching and management love RNH, he's not going anywhere. Not to mention that Edmonton's center depth becomes paper-thin the minute RNH is dealt.
Regardless, Oilers coaching and management love RNH, he's not going anywhere. Not to mention that Edmonton's center depth becomes paper-thin the minute RNH is dealt.
Jumptheshark
Rebooting myself
Do not tell that to nucks fans. SOME believe he is top 10 in the league and a few suggested it would have only been small add to get Matthews at the sraft
Got a link for that? If you honestly believe any rational canucks fan believes that you've truly lost your marbles.
Not even a nuck fan, but Tanev is easily a top pairing dman. Yeah he can't do offense but his defensive ability is amazing and makes him a great #2.
PG Canuck
Registered User
- Mar 29, 2010
- 63,606
- 25,637
Hansen is actually a really good piece, it's Sutter that is meh, and the Oilers could do without. Hansen would actually fit in very nice on the Oilers roster.
Ad
Latest posts
-
GDT: 2024-25 season game 18 LA Kings vs Colorado Avalanche @7:00pm 11/13/24- Latest: Raccoon Jesus
-
-
-
-
