I've been pretty vocal about it but I extend Freddy. I don't think Frederic is the consistent 40 point scorer like last year but he's not the 20 point scorer this year either when many others have been performing below expectations. He's likely somewhere in the middle.
Take Tom Wilson for example. Last year on a very pedestrian Capitals team that squeaked into the playoffs, he had 35 points. It was one of his worst statistical years and he was a disappointment. Let me remind you, he gets FIVE more minutes of ice time per game than Freddy and PP1 time. Thats just simply not top six production. But guess what...he rebounded and is having a career year at 30 because the whole team is better.
Take Lawson Crouse...he has like 10 more points than Freddy over the past three years and he plays in Utah's top six. Half this fanbase drools over him.
Now is the perfect time to try to buy low on Frederic. Give him a little bit of term to get the AAV down, play with him Poitras and get an actual top six forward to improve the whole team and then watch as all of a sudden you start seeing a player closer to last year.
Trading him for a 2nd round pick doesn't improve this team. Getting better players around him does.