My god have you seen KK play this year or this playoff? He was on the 4th line and almost healthy scratch .You think Carolina deciding if they buy him back is not a red flag? He skates like Bambi literally.
Dvorak can play on the PK , defensively and hes decent on the dot. Dvorak is tradeable and could be worth something at this TDL if he stays healthy for a team looking for Depth at the Center in case of injuries. While KK can't even steal 550 year olds Jordan Stall center's position.
Id take Dvorak everytime over KK.
I still think we handled KK development terribly but hes 23 , clearly that OS was for a payback on AHO and turned horribly for Carolina.
A few errors in your logic:
1. He was on the 4th line for a cup contender. Dvorak was on lines 3-4 on a team that was 5th worst in the NHL. It doesn't get better when you look at the center depth of each team.
2. If he stays healthy. Over the last three seasons he's played 56, 64 and 30 games played. Over the same span Kotkaniemi has had seasons of 66, 82 and 79 games.
3. Dvorak had 70 pts for a ppg of .47, while Kotkaniemi had 99 for a .44 ppg. I didn't tally the numbers, but if you equate to points/60 minutes, Kotkaniemi comes out ahead.
4. KK is 23 and could still round out his game. Dvorak is 28 and a finished product.
Yeah, you haven't sold me on anything yet. But then again, this like arguing is shit grosser than vomit.
I'd rather have an extra locker than deal with 800k of actual dead cap space for 12 years.
Also I wouldn't rule out Dvorak returning something at the deadline. No matter how vanilla, he can still be useful on the PK and is good on faceoffs.
What, a 6th rounder? I'd bet KK would return at least a 5th. With no retention. But you're right, the obligation ends at the end of the season. That counts for a lot. But the point wasn't arguing who's the better player. The original point was that Bergevin was dumber for trading a 1st and 2nd rounder for Dvorak than Waddell was for signing a 21-year old 3rd overall pick (even if that was a stretch) to what essentially became a 9-year $44,660,020.00 contract. All it cost him was a first rounder.
But once again, douche vs. turd sandwich.