HF Habs: Trade Proposal Thread #87: 2024 Season Finale

[ZUKI]

If not Necas, i would really like Habs to sign my Monahan guy. He's such a good fit; puts points and a good mentor for the young guns. He would have a good influence on Roy, Dach and on Demidov or Iginla

 

[ZUKI]

Kane would have no interest in Montreal and did he and Kane work with Chicago?

is it your 2 cents or it's from a valuable source ?

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

is it your 2 cents or it's from a valuable source ?

Logic. Why would Kane have any interest in a team that isn't likely to contend this season?

 

[Saundies]

Logic. Why would Kane have any interest in a team that isn't likely to contend this season?

I mean he chose the Red Wings last year.

Not saying he'd ever come here but if he was contender or bust, I think he would have chosen a different team than Detroit. Just saying.

 

[ZUKI]

Logic. Why would Kane have any interest in a team that isn't likely to contend this season?

Because Habs are the Mecque of hockey. It's the best place to be a Star for someone that carbure with the crowd noises

 

[SwiftyHab]

Because Habs are the Mecque of hockey. It's the best place to be a Star for someone that carbure with the crowd noises

We can give him the same deal as Detroit. If we’re not in the playoffs by the TDL, he can pick where he wants to go

 

[Deus ex machina]

Kane would have no interest in Montreal and did he and Dach work with Chicago?

I can't know for sure. Can you?
Worth a try.

Dach is not the same player he was in Chicago. I just remember that Kane was pissed when they traded Dach.

 

[Deus ex machina]

Logic. Why would Kane have any interest in a team that isn't likely to contend this season?

Maybe he wants to get paid.
Most contenders don't have the cap space.

 

[McGees]

Dach is not the same player he was in Chicago.

Ya now he watches games from the press box.

 

[Rapala]

Absolutely. Unfortunately the deeper you go in the playoffs the harder in gets to manufacture scoring chances it just becomes a grind fest. You need horses that can play a heavy game and suffocate. The D we had the year we went to finals was an absolute nightmare to play against. I would take my chances and keep someone like Xhekaj, he can develop into an absolute unicorn for us. He was really good after he got back up from ahl and I think he will only get better, still so young for a defenseman.

Indeed.
Reminds me of the Suzuki talk before last season.
What Arber has accomplished in the limited time spent playing at an elite level is incredible.
Why would anyone think a Dman of his age in those circumstances is a finished product?
I don't know what Xhekaj's ceiling is but I'm positive he hasn't reached it yet.

 

[Deus ex machina]

Ya now he watches games from the press box.

For the rest of his career, no doubt...

 

[Boss Man Hughes]

I mean he chose the Red Wings last year.

Not saying he'd ever come here but if he was contender or bust, I think he would have chosen a different team than Detroit. Just saying.

True. Either he thought Detroit was a contender or he didn't care. If he is willing to sign with a team and go to a contender at the deadline he might sign with Montreal. But if a contender offers him a deal now he will probably go there.

 

[Runner77]

we need to start thinking out side the box.

who out there is like a Dach that KH would target??

Dach’s brother.

Perhaps he too has a genetic predisposition for freak injuries.

 

[Kudo Shinichi]

I have no interest in paying a big price for Necas or Zegras. I'd do it for someone who pushes the needle, but they don't.

So basically you're not interested in acquiring a top forward in a trade since players that are a good amount better than Zegras/Necas are pretty much never available.

 

[Egresch]

If Zegras and Necas are off the menu then maybe it's Laine time.

We could have a massive 2nd line of Laine-Dach-Lindstrom that play a combined total of 15 games per season!

In all seriousness though, I hope Hughes inquires on him to see where Columbus stands.

They only need to play 16 games. Mark Stone Memorial line.

 

[CanadienShark]

Trade 1 but only happens after Trade 2 is approved by the Devils
* Flames 1st
* Jets 1st
* B prospect add or Avs 2nd.
for
* Markstrom

Trade 2:
* Markstrom at 50% retention
* B prospect add potentially
for
10th OA

Draft Iggy 5th. Then see who drops to 10th. Don't like who drops? Trade 10th OA for Zegras.

We don't trade any of our D to make this happen and we walk away with Iggy and Zegras or one of Catton/Eiserman/Sennecke.

What in the f***!?!?

Markstrom doesn't even fetch a single 1st in my mind. Holy crap. At most he's worth Avs 2nd + B prospect.

 

[Habs Halifax]

What in the f***!?!?

Markstrom doesn't even fetch a single 1st in my mind. Holy crap. At most he's worth Avs 2nd + B prospect.

I think mine is at the absolute high and and you went absolute low. Markstrom due to supply/demand, is going to cost more than what you think. Truth is likely in the middle.

It ends up being Jets and Flames 1st with a 2nd to get the 10th OA. You are overlooking this idea because your caught on Markstrom.

 

[morhilane]

Dach’s brother.

Perhaps he too has a genetic predisposition for freak injuries.

Oh Colton sure do.

 

[Tuggy]

So basically you're not interested in acquiring a top forward in a trade since players that are a good amount better than Zegras/Necas are pretty much never available.

I don't consider them top forwards. I think both are a little overrated to be honest.

 

[Habs Halifax]

I mean he chose the Red Wings last year.

Not saying he'd ever come here but if he was contender or bust, I think he would have chosen a different team than Detroit. Just saying.

Many teams who were real contenders had cap issues. I think this is why he picked the Wings who were expected to rise in the standings.

Cap grew a bit so I do see him signing with a team who has a real shot at the playoffs. The cap tight seasons are about to loosen a bit.

 

[CanadienShark]

I think mine is at the absolute high and and you went absolute low. Markstrom due to supply/demand, is going to cost more than what you think. Truth is likely in the middle.

It ends up being Jets and Flames 1st with a 2nd to get the 10th OA. You are overlooking this idea because your caught on Markstrom.

In the 10th overall thread even Flames fans are recognizing Markstrom won't be the main piece to get that pick, but you're arguing Markstrom + B prospect gets it done? No chance.

 

[Habs Halifax]

I don't consider them top forwards. I think both are a little overrated to be honest.

This is fair.

Necas scares me. He's trended well right up to that critical spot after his bridge and wants a big contract. Cost to acquire in a trade and cost of contract are too high for me. You don't have the ability to add him as a RFA and then sign him to a bridge like Dach and Newhook. He's a bit more established and in his prime. Is he a real top 6F talent? I have my doubts on that. My gut tells me his a very good middle 6F (higher end of this waive like Newhook) but wants to be paid like Suzuki.

Zegras's value is not as high after his rough season. It's still not that low but I do think he helps our team but not with grit. At least with Zegras, you trade for his 2 year bridge left and you get to see him on our roster before you commit to the longer contract (like Necas).

I'd be somewhat interested in Zegras but not Necas. It has to be a trade we can afford though

 

[Habs Halifax]

In the 10th overall thread even Flames fans are recognizing Markstrom won't be the main piece to get that pick, but you're arguing Markstrom + B prospect gets it done? No chance.

You're overlooking the main point again because your getting caught in the weeds. Stuck on Markstrom and zero talk about the retention which the Devils would be interested in big time.

Break down the same strategy but with your trade valuations in it. Lets me nit pick you like the paper boy in Ski School chasing people around for his $2.

ski school where is my $2 - Google Suche

 

[BLONG7]

Logic. Why would Kane have any interest in a team that isn't likely to contend this season?

He went to Detroit last year?? Weird for a guy who was chasing a Cup.

This is fair.

Necas scares me. He's trended well right up to that critical spot after his bridge and wants a big contract. Cost to acquire in a trade and cost of contract are too high for me. You don't have the ability to add him as a RFA and then sign him to a bridge like Dach and Newhook. He's a bit more established and in his prime. Is he a real top 6F talent? I have my doubts on that. My gut tells me his a very good middle 6F (higher end of this waive like Newhook) but wants to be paid like Suzuki.

Zegras's value is not as high after his rough season. It's still not that low but I do think he helps our team but not with grit. At least with Zegras, you trade for his 2 year bridge left and you get to see him on our roster before you commit to the longer contract (like Necas).

I'd be somewhat interested in Zegras but not Necas. It has to be a trade we can afford though

Any idea as t why Verbeek wants Zegras gone???

 

[Habs Icing]

Dach’s brother.

Perhaps he too has a genetic predisposition for freak injuries.

C'mon, Runner, you know better than that. Freak injuries are ruled by astrology, not genetic predisposition.