GDT: - Trade and Free agent Rumours thread | Chayka off-season edition | Page 439 | HFBoards - NHL Message Board and Forum for National Hockey League

GDT: Trade and Free agent Rumours thread | Chayka off-season edition

  • If you are having issues logging in, we have found opening the log in page in a new tab/window rather than using the pop out should resolve these issues. We are working to get this resolved and thank you for patience.
  • Xenforo Cloud is upgrading us to version 2.3.11 on Monday July 20, 2026 at 12:00 AM PST. Expect a temporary downtime during this process. More info here
  • Due to the increased volume of league transactions, the Trade Rumors and Free Agent Talk section is temporarily restricted to where threads may only be started by moderators and sponsors. We anticipate that this restriction will be lifted some time after the first round of the draft.
Doubt Columbus has any interest in Nylander for Werenski. That doesn’t help them at all. Are they a Nylander away from being a Cup champ? Most likely losing your Norris D equals rebuild. You want Cowan, 1sts, Danford, etc. These guys also just tasted AHL victory. That’s my opinion of what Columbus would want. A rebuild.
The 29 Toronto first rounder could be interesting as well because there's a shot Matthews and Werenski walk but they won't if they are both here
 
Dreger is a World class bullshit artist, virtually nothing he says has any merit. Watch him when he is asked an "insider" question, he literally does the two step, talks for and extended period of time and says nothing "insider-ish" and people go Ohhh...Ahhhh... good info.

Virtually any Insider connected with Columbus says that Columbus is not interested in futures, they want people who are ready to play NHL minutes today.

They have Jet Reaves, I doubt Hildby is going there. Morgan or OEL? Possibly. Willie? Hollywood Willie is going to waive his contract to go to the BFN Columbus, OH? I dont see it. Matthews is going no where, would they want Tavares and would he waive? Probably not.

So that leaves

Knies
Cowan
Rielly
Joshua
Lorenz

Is any of that worth a Norris Dman? Maybe Knies, Cowan, Colorado's 1st - am I getting close?
When players limit the teams down to one or two the returns are usually below the main players value. I'm sure Knies if part of any deal but you still jump at the chance and then FINALLY trade Rielly.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hellcat
The man sits in a massive Whitby Mansion and is still making $200k a year from TSN to make stuff up. He gets told stuff by player Agents to fluff up their players and in turn he gets some insider information
I think he lives in Brooklyn but the rest is right. Dazzle them with bullshit if you can't dazzle them with brilliance.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: thewave and Hellcat
Not him; best C prospect we have. I'd rather go with other stuff.

But honestly, I wouldn't pursue it that hard. I'd much rather go for a younger dman that falls in line more with a McKenna-based group.

Remember, we have no idea which version of Auston Matthews exists, and if it turns out to be closer to the guy from the last two years, then all of this is mostly for naught. I have no issue helping the team via free agency, as they have already with Raddysh, and likely Bob (assuming the contract isn't awful) because it's just money and they've got tons of cap space, but giving up the future for a 2-year run in terms of assets is not preferable.

Losing TLK does hurt our C depth but you have to give to get.
Matthews outlook is a fair concern and if he doesn't return to form this move won't work out as well but a case could also be made that Werenski will drastically help Matthews return to that level of scoring, even if he's not as dynamic as before. I personally think this guy is just too good and you almost never get a chance to grab this type of talent, that I would take the risk, especially considering their timelines directly lineup with McDavid's free agency.

There's always lots of risk with these types of deals but the upside is tremendous.
 
Doubt Columbus has any interest in Nylander for Werenski. That doesn’t help them at all. Are they a Nylander away from being a Cup champ? Most likely losing your Norris D equals rebuild. You want Cowan, 1sts, Danford, etc. These guys also just tasted AHL victory. That’s my opinion of what Columbus would want. A rebuild.
0% chance Willy waives for anything unless its clear the leafs are going through a long term rebuild.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kb and Hellcat
they are at the mercy of what other teams are willing to offer tho right? like if the teams interested are only willing to give future packages then there choice is to take one or keep the player and eventually lose him for nothing?

alot of Ducks fans on here were saying that because they just made the playoffs they wouldn't be interested in future packages for McTavish and Zellweger, and that they would want to use them to improve the team now, which made perfect sense but yet they decided to take futures packages, maybe because that's the only deals they could make.

Very true, there is what you want, and then what you an get. I'm living it right now, trying to sell my wife's SUV for a fair market and the Stealerships are trying to bend me over with stupid low ball offers.
 
Dreger is a World class bullshit artist, virtually nothing he says has any merit. Watch him when he is asked an "insider" question, he literally does the two step, talks for and extended period of time and says nothing "insider-ish" and people go Ohhh...Ahhhh... good info.

Virtually any Insider connected with Columbus says that Columbus is not interested in futures, they want people who are ready to play NHL minutes today.

They have Jet Reaves, I doubt Hildby is going there. Morgan or OEL? Possibly. Willie? Hollywood Willie is going to waive his contract to go to the BFN Columbus, OH? I dont see it. Matthews is going no where, would they want Tavares and would he waive? Probably not.

So that leaves

Knies
Cowan
Rielly
Joshua
Lorenz

Is any of that worth a Norris Dman? Maybe Knies, Cowan, Colorado's 1st - am I getting close?
Joshua has a modified NTC of 12 teams, Rielly a full no movement
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hellcat
Knies is def in the package if we trade for him. Me personally, I dont love trading for him and dont see the love of him. I get it hes a good defenseman. But we have bigger problems on the roster...
A top defenseman is literally the single biggest problem on the roster. This will be a transformational trade for the franchise.
 
Yah I’d be leery of dangling that …
Yeah that’s a no for me. Colorado 27 is in play. That’s the end. At least with Matthews/McKenna/Knies/JT/Nylander/Raddysh/Werenski, our next 2 years owing Boston and Philly should be non lottery picks. That way we have ours back in 29 depending on what happens. That is smart business.
 
I want not part of Warenski. Danford and Cowan and a 1st? That is literally all our prospects and leverage for a defenseman? No thank you brother
We could land an 80+ point, Norris winning defenseman in his prime, something the organization has literally never had and you're worried about a middle 6 forward, a potential top 4 defenseman down the road and a late 1st round pick?... My dude.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Ad

Ad