This guy has really interesting stats to look at.
Even if we dismiss the analytic charts showing him with the 6th best xGA out of the 326 forwards to play 1500+ 5v5 minutes the last 3 seasons, how does he do with more solid numbers? Actual hits, goals against, and differentials?
5v5 Ozone start%: 33.17 (14th lowest out of 326)
Hits/60: 13.12 (15th most out of 326)
Actual 5v5 goals against/60 the last 3 years: 1.55 (3rd lowest out of 326, 1st fewest REL)
Actual 5v5 goal differential/60 the last 3 years: 56.27% (62nd out of 326, pretty much identical to Crosby's GF%)
He may suck in a lot of ways but he was sure effective out there in his role IMO. Buried in defensive zone starts and apparently one of the hardest forwards in the league to score goals against.
Considering our 4th line was certainly an issue last season, I'll take those numbers all day. It seemed to translate over to the Ducks (along with his ability to blow offensive chances) but the end results look good to me. It's not a small sample here. It's a full 3 years with even better relative numbers for both underlying AND outcomes.
I'm surprised he's still available but who knows what's going on behind the scenes.