Proposal: TML-PHI- SJS. Update ***

[cup67]

SJS- Hertl , 50% retained. Has a 3 team trade clause. Czech friends with leafs , just saying
TML- 1st 2022, Robertson, maybe now Robertson is to much

PHI- Braun 50% retained
TML- 2nd 2022, 7th 2022

Mikheyev- trade for a 3rd pick or better
Dermott- trade for a 3rd pick or better
Ritchie - trade , add a 3rd 2022 and a 5th 2023
Sign - Ho- Sang 750 000 before deadline.

Bunting- Matthews- Marner
Hertl- Tavares- Nylander
Kerfoot- Kempf- Kase
Engval- Spezza- Simmonds
Ho-Sang
Rielly- Braun
Muzzin-Brodie
Sandin - Holl
Liljegren

Click to read more...

 

[Groo]

That looks bad for SJ

 

[Jerkbait]

San Jose says NO. Nobody is giving a 3rd for dermott right now. Start over

 

[WSS11]

SJ is going to want more.

 

[Irie]

San Jose fans aren't going to like this, because replacing Hertl with anything less than a guaranteed star prospect is going to likely be a downgrade, but for a pure rental, that is honestly decent value. A 1st + top prospect is more than most rentals could ever hope to return.

The Braun deal seems about right with retention.

 

[themelkman]

Its not terrible, but I think SJ will ask more.

 

[BrindamoursNose]

Deal

 

[Gecklund]

I’m not fully opposed to it as I think k Robertson will be a solid player but I’d want more from TOR. A 3rd or another equivalent prospect to the 3rd.

 

[Bruhin]

Yikes. Here's a live look at Doug Wilson after receiving that Hertl offer.

 

[HockeyVirus]

Ok not going to even comment on the proposals, I want to know why the Leafs are blowing up one of the best offenses in the league and gutting their depth. Braun isn't a top pairing D and Rielly - Brodie have been outstanding all season.

Makes no sense for the Leafs to add another skilled player anyways. They have more than enough scorers they need grit in their top 9 and an upgrade on Holl. This blows the Leafs load, disrupts team chemistry, and the team is no better when Hertl walks in a few months.

 

[Ziggdiezan]

Don't see the leafs parting with their best forward prospect and a 1st for a rental no matter how good they are. Got burned bad last year and Dubas seems to be targeting guys with more term.

 

[cup67]

SJ is going to want more.

He’s a UFA , maybe they can work it out , 2nd 2023

 

[cup67]

Don't see the leafs parting with their best forward prospect and a 1st for a rental no matter how good they are. Got burned bad last year and Dubas seems to be targeting guys with more term.

Leafs have no cap space moving forward

 

[cup67]

Ok not going to even comment on the proposals, I want to know why the Leafs are blowing up one of the best offenses in the league and gutting their depth. Braun isn't a top pairing D and Rielly - Brodie have been outstanding all season.
They tried the tough guy approach last year but needed goals to win a round .

Makes no sense for the Leafs to add another skilled player anyways. They have more than enough scorers they need grit in their top 9 and an upgrade on Holl. This blows the Leafs load, disrupts team chemistry, and the team is no better when Hertl walks in a few months.

 

[cup67]

Ok not going to even comment on the proposals, I want to know why the Leafs are blowing up one of the best offenses in the league and gutting their depth. Braun isn't a top pairing D and Rielly - Brodie have been outstanding all season.



Makes no sense for the Leafs to add another skilled player anyways. They have more than enough scorers they need grit in their top 9 and an upgrade on Holl. This blows the Leafs load, disrupts team chemistry, and the team is no better when Hertl walks in a few months.

Leafs tried the tough guy approach last year and they needed scoring to win a round

 

[Ziggdiezan]

Leafs have no cap space moving forward

Wouldn't that make 1st rounders and good prospects even more important?

 

[cup67]

San Jose says NO. Nobody is giving a 3rd for dermott right now. Start over

What’s he worth ?

 

[cup67]

Wouldn't that make 1st rounders and good prospects even more important?

when do the leafs go for the cup , after Matthews etc move on ?
The leafs need to take a chance this year

 

[cup67]

That looks bad for SJ

What’s Hertl worth ? Maybe they could add another pick 2023

 

[cup67]

SJ is going to want more.

Top prospect and a 1st and he resigns with sharks again in the summer.

 

[Ziggdiezan]

when do the leafs go for the cup , after Matthews etc move on ?
The leafs need to take a chance this year

It will be the hardest 1st round they will probably face for a very long time. Not the year to blow a ton of futures on a rental. Plus they haven't shown anything to warrant that much faith in the team. They will live and die by the big 4 and Campbell.

 

[cup67]

Its not terrible, but I think SJ will ask more.

Maybe add a 3rd 2023

 

[Hodge]

Sharks should take this and run IMO. Which superior prospect to Robertson do people think a team would trade to rent Hertl?

 

[cup67]

It will be the hardest 1st round they will probably face for a very long time. Not the year to blow a ton of futures on a rental. Plus they haven't shown anything to warrant that much faith in the team. They will live and die by the big 4 and Campbell.

They have prospects, that are 3 to 4 years away . Leafs team this year is good add and it could put them over the top .
3 solid lines scoring

 

[Groo]

What’s Hertl worth ? Maybe they could add another pick 2023

How about a much better prospect. Including a middling pick doesn't in any way tip the scales