@Hellcat @Gary Nylund
Have you guys tried Ardbeg? Very smokey/peaty.
Another underrated scotch is Aberfeldy. Good value price wise too.
I've tried both. I tried Ardbeg many years ago, didn't like it as much as Laphroaig IIRC (and Laphroaig is less pricey) but I've been thinking I need to try it again as I do love Islay whiskeys and sometimes you love a whiskey one day, another time it doesn't impress you as much etc. so I might just love it when I try it again. I have so much whiskey on hand right now though so I probably won't buy anything else for a while.
I liked Aberfeldy, thought it was great value. Not sure if I'll get it again cause I've sort of figured out what my faves are and I just stick to those now. I also have 3 unopened single malts on the shelf ATM and I'm mostly drinking bourbon lately. That said, I signed up for LCBO notifications for Laphroaig 10 Sherry Oak, I bought a bottle last year, it was great and when it comes in again I'm definitely picking up another bottle. Here are my faves.
Scotch
==============
Lagavulin 16
Lagavulin Distillers Edition (not always available)
Lagavulin Offerman edition (not always available)
Lagavulin 8
Laphroaig 10
Laphroaig 1/4 Cask
Laphroaig 10 Sherry Oak (not always available)
Auchentoshan Three Wood
Honorable mention to Caol Ila.
Bourbon
===============
EH Taylor (not always available)
Blantons (not always available)
Eagle Rare (not always available)
Weller Antique (not always available)
Weller Special Reserve (not always available)
Knob Creek Single Barrel
Wild Turkey Rare Breed
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked
The first 5 bourbons are all from Buffalo Trace, they come in twice a year last couple of years, limit 1 bottle per customer and I'm on the notification list. When they come in I buy them, they are the ones I like the best and I don't need to buy much else as a man can only drink so much.
Edit - I haven't actually tried Lagavulin Distillers Edition yet but I picked up a bottle about 6 weeks ago, and I'm quite confident it belongs on the list of my favorites, perhaps even right at the top displacing Lagavulin 16, we'll see.