I have no interest in joining the debate but I did come across a few articles and timeline elements that may be helpful.
Well…Flyers hockey is officially back. After many years of a boring, uninspired, corporate brand of hockey, the Philadelphia Flyers organization re-discovered their fastball. Even casual fans are now perked up after the drama this past week as the Flyers traded their top North American prospect...
www.flyersnation.com
Elliotte Friedman releases an article
Sportsnet insider Elliotte Friedman added another layer to this saga when he
released an article that was meant to clarify what happened. It really didn’t explain much besides something happening after the 2023 World Championship in March being a turning point. Friedman explains how many of his sources believe it was a cap problem with his entry-level contract and that he wanted to turn pro and not wait until the cap situation figured itself out. Weird that this could’ve happened from something so small, maybe there was more?
Gauthier speaks
Cutter Gauthier finally talks after two days of silence. Gauthier sat down on the Ducks’
Light the Lamp podcast and opened up (not really) about the situation. He just continued to say how it was a personal private matter and gave no further explanation. Gauthier did however dump a bucket of water on the Kevin Hayes fire. He said that Hayes was not involved in the decision at all.
Gauthier accidentally backs himself into a corner
The whole time this situation has been in the spotlight, Gauthier kept reiterating that it was a private, personal, family matter.
In an
article written by Derek Lee of The Sporting Tribune, Gauthier was quoted as saying this:
“It wasn’t one specific reason why I asked for a trade. It was multiple, re-occurring issues that I’d seen over the past year and a half, two years of being under the Flyers organization. [Everything] kind of hit me all at once, thinking ‘I can’t move forward with this’ and ‘I really need to step up for myself and see what’s best for my future’ and that’s what I did.”
A telling quote. A completely different tone than his previous quotes on the matter.
Gauthier also said that there could be one day where he tells the details of what happened but for right now he kind of want to keep it to a private matter. As we already know earlier in the week, Elliotte Friedman reported Gauthier wanted to turn pro, but Gauthier stated he did not want to communicate with the franchise because of these “reoccurring issues.” A weird corner to back yourself into where there seems to be no way out.
One of the biggest surprises was when Brière said that they thought he was NHL ready after the World Championship. Many reports said the Flyers asked him to return to Boston College for another season, but this was not the case. Something apparently happened that Brière doesn’t know about because the last he had heard was he wanted to still be a Flyer but wanted to go back to Boston College another year. He also once again reiterated that he completely cut off the Flyers and he and his family wouldn’t even communicate with the Flyers about the team’s future vision.
In a shocking trade Monday night, the Flyers traded Cutter Gauthier to Anaheim after the player made it clear he did not want to play in Philadelphia anymore. So what happened? Elliotte Friedman tries to make sense of the situation.
www.sportsnet.ca
According to several sources, whatever happened pre-dates May 11, when Keith Jones was hired and Daniel Briere officially became general manager. The last time they met face-to-face with Gauthier was on a Zoom call right after the World Championships, which concluded May 28. At that time, the Flyers were hoping Gauthier was ready to sign, only to be floored by hearing he would never do so.
Several sources believe that whatever discussions took place after March 11 — when Boston College’s 2022-23 season ended with a loss in the Hockey East quarterfinals — threw an unintentional wrench into this relationship.
However, after the trade was announced, it was reported that Gauthier had indicated to the Flyers that he didn't intend to sign with the team. The 19-year-old is currently a sophomore at Boston College but is widely expected to turn pro following the NCAA season.
www.sportsnet.ca
Flyers GM Daniel Briere said Gauthier was enthusiastic about joining the Flyers ahead of the 2022 draft but informed the team in the spring of 2023, after returning from the world championships, that he would not be signing with them.
Briere said at the time the Flyers chose to wait and see if Gauthier would reconsider. But after he and Jones travelled to Sweden to meet with Gauthier during the world juniors, and that meeting was declined, the Flyers decided to close the deal with Anaheim.
“It was a long time coming,” Briere said. “It’s been going on for a while. We tried to give him space. We tried to get in touch with him many times. He would not communicate ... so at some point, we had to make a decision, and we thought with what happened just a few days ago, this was probably the time to get the highest value.”