scrubadam
Registered User
- Apr 10, 2016
- 12,438
- 1,904
While missing the MVP Markov for almost the entire span of those 3 seasons.
So let me get this straight, you think that the big difference was adding MT and Prust, right???
Not the additions of Markov, Gally and Chucky?
No I think that MT took a decent team and got good results out of em for most of the time he was here. What more do you want from the guy? First 3 years 4th/9th/2nd in the NHL. Last year half the season top 8 team.
Comeon we read all day long about how MB sucks and didn't do anything for the team did you really expect MT to turn the habs into the Hawks or LA? His C line was DD/Pleks/Eller and teenager AG. Outside of Max he didn't have much top 6 unless you want to count Cole/Ryder/PAP/Briere. D was thin outside of Markov/PK. The pieces were decent but it was not a top 10 roster but the results were top 10. Don't give the man any credit fine, while as a passenger he did what he was hired to do, which is win hockey games. I know that there is a side that will never admit that the coach could possibly have even a % of influence on the wins the team had, but 100% the losses are all on him. That's the bias. I don't give MT 100% credit for the team, the players play. But Wins and losses it what matter and the team under MT did a lot more winning. And personally I think winning close games even with a goalie having to be great is pretty exciting hockey. It keeps you watching till the end. You didn't enjoy 12/13/14 a lot more than what we are watching now?
I don't care how the results were achieved, he got em. Once the team spiraled and he had no answers IMO the team turned on him. He got a 2nd chance, the players gave him a 2nd chance, and the minute things started to slip they tuned him out again and he was gone. An abrasive coach like MT is always going to have a short shelf life. He went to Pitts and got em to a cup final and the team still tuned him out the following year. After 3.5 years he eventually turned the players on him and it cost him his job. But those first 3 years were a very fun ride as a fan.
If MB hired Hartly instead would the team had the same results we will never know. We only know what actually happened and to me what happened at the start at least wasn't as bad as some want to paint it. But this is really about how much an ass MT is and I don't disagree that he was probably a big jerk to his players. But I don't really care how he treated pampered millionaires who probably always got treated like they were special their entire lives. They deserved each other LOL.