The Great Dale Weise Debate (& other ex-Hawks) volume 3

[LDF]

No hate. Forsling needs seasoning, as does Gus, Rutta and more than likely Snugs as well.

I repeat, Hawks need to get serious about bringing in a solid defenseman who actually can play defense. Otherwise, the growing pains will continue.

the big difference here and you are pointing out is logic. we and i would guess many would assume to agree with you on bringing in an experience top fa d-men. however we are talking about SB.

 

[x Tame Impala]

Can we change the thread title to just the "Ex-Hawks" or something like that? With as much wit as a mod/the OP can muster

 

[ClydeLee]

Shaw had a troubling run in taking a big run at a guy on the Stars and knocking himself out on the hit.

 

[Hawkaholic]

Wingels went from a great opening game with Boston to being a healthy scratch last night.

 

[AmericanDream]

Pateryn had a lot of nice things to say about Shaw after that hit...yikes... said this is why the guy gets like 4-5 concussions per year, he has no sorrow for him...cant say I blame Pateryn either, when you play like a wrecking ball at times you get what you give.

 

[BK]

Pateryn had a lot of nice things to say about Shaw after that hit...yikes... said this is why the guy gets like 4-5 concussions per year, he has no sorrow for him...cant say I blame Pateryn either, when you play like a wrecking ball at times you get what you give.

What did he say?

 

[LDF]

Pateryn had a lot of nice things to say about Shaw after that hit...yikes... said this is why the guy gets like 4-5 concussions per year, he has no sorrow for him...cant say I blame Pateryn either, when you play like a wrecking ball at times you get what you give.

it also looks to me as he also hit the edge of the , where the board and the glass meets.

 

[AmericanDream]

What did he say?

Pateryn said "this is why the guy gets like 4-5 concussions per year, he has no sorrow for him" he ripped into Shaw for like 3 minutes, it was pretty damn good.

 

[ChiHawks10]

it also looks to me as he also hit the edge of the , where the board and the glass meets.

He was unconscious before he ever hit the boards. He went cold as soon as his jaw hit Pateryn's helmet. The hit on the boards didn't help things, but he was already out at that point.

Hell, Pateryn punching him in the face is probably what woke him back up...

 

[ColdSteel2]

You appreciate the moxie but Shaw needs to be better about picking his battles, that guy is huge.

 

[LDF]

He was unconscious before he ever hit the boards. He went cold as soon as his jaw hit Pateryn's helmet. The hit on the boards didn't help things, but he was already out at that point.

Hell, Pateryn punching him in the face is probably what woke him back up...

ref bold 1, that i didn't know, thanks for that little tidbit.

bold 2. sorry but that is extremely funny.

 

[DisgruntledHawkFan]

I don't miss Shaw. At all.

 

[LDF]

i don't miss A. Shaw esp at his present salary hit.

 

[BobbyJet]

Shaw had a troubling run in taking a big run at a guy on the Stars and knocking himself out on the hit.

Shaw was sucker punched twice by Greg Pateryn while he lay on the ice, dazed and defenseless. I expect a substantial suspension will result.

 

[DisgruntledHawkFan]

Shaw was sucker punched twice by Greg Pateryn while he lay on the ice, dazed and defenseless. I expect a substantial suspension will result.

Pateryn had no idea he was out. He knocked him out with the crown of his head.

 

[AmericanDream]

I don't miss Shaw. At all.

yep, and we were just talking about this in the Marchand thread we were all discussing...and boom, here you go!! though I wouldnt call this a "cheap shot", Shaw was late with the hit, was aiming up towards the upper body/head area...it is a garbage play and Shaw deserves we he got out of it...some nice punches to his mashed potato head as well...

 

[b1e9a8r5s]

Shaw was sucker punched twice by Greg Pateryn while he lay on the ice, dazed and defenseless. I expect a substantial suspension will result.

No chance. He stopped once he realized Shaw was out.

 

[BobbyJet]

No chance. He stopped once he realized Shaw was out.

So that makes it ok?

 

[DisgruntledHawkFan]

So that makes it ok?

Yea, intent is every bit of a sucker punch. Don't think there's any here. He just got hit in the head by Shaw on a play Shaw didn't need to go high on. He responded.

 

[AmericanDream]

So that makes it ok?

yes!

 

[ChiHawk21]

i thought it was a pretty good hit by shaw. i realize there heads must have hit but i didnt even see it. this guy sounds butt hurt.

i miss shaw big time and i think the hawks do too.

 

[BK]

I don't miss Shaw. At all.

Either do I.

 

[Hawkaholic]

Pateryn had no idea he was out. He knocked him out with the crown of his head.

Yeah?



..and why are people railing on Shaw? He tried to lay a hit, not dirty IMO, and got the worst of it.

 

[BobbyJet]

Yeah?



..and why are people railing on Shaw? He tried to lay a hit, not dirty IMO, and got the worst of it.

Exactly. I can't believe folks think it is okay to sucker punch a guy when he's already down on the ice. Conscious or not. 3 games minimum.

As for Shaw: I said when I first saw Shaw play with Hawks that he wouldn't be able to play like that for too long. I reckon his NHL career is close to being over. Getting suckered like that doesn't help.

Quiz: Does Pateryn get suspended?

 

[RayP]

I don’t miss Shaw, but I was fine with him being a Hawk while he was. He brought something different to this team no one else did and no one else has since he left.