I don't know why you can't both 1) celebrate, be optimistic and follow closely a particular prospect and 2) have realistic expectations for that prospect's outcome.
I don't really understand why some posters feel like they are being attacked personally when a prospect is "criticized" or whatever, but its a phenomenon that's been occurring here at HF for decades.
As an example, when Jake Virtanen played like shit in the WJCs I remember everyone on this board that criticized him at all were absolutely obliterated by many who were willing to defend him to the end.
Most posters who have been around have complete understanding of the odds associated with prospects and pics. Having them repeated ad nauseam to contradict peoples positive upsides gets cold and dismissive.
I welcome criticism and arguments with conviction as it's the only way to create better outcomes and opinions. I don't take player perspectives personally.
And in contrast to your statement about Virtanen there are many who shit talk anyone who are not high end impact players. Prospect success is measured by the eye of the beholder it's not just 10yrs of clueless "defend them to the end" posting if expectations have altered and success for Podkolzin or Virtanen for example is 30-35pts and a heavy 2 way 3rd liner vs the top6 PF we were hoping for. Hoglander has been traded 100x this summer and shit talked?
Lekkerimaki and EP2 are players with a lot worth defending at this stage from my perspective.
The odds are always stacked against them. Most draft years are lucky to have 15 players with what would be considered impact. It's kinda pointless to say without first seeing how someone adapts to the AHL what he projects as and even then some patience is required.
As far as getting obliterated by criticisms of players go tell Moms how shitty their kid is and get back to me. Fans get attached...it is what it is. Everyone has different levels of skin/emotions in their fandom and that's kinda what we do here. You're a good poster Hodgy i usually agree with your takes