Boom Boom Apathy
I am the Professor. Deal with it!
- Sep 6, 2006
- 49,337
- 102,085
If we’re going direct comparisons Laughton is younger, faster, plays a more aggressive style, and takes the puck to the net harder and more frequently. That’s the style we want if we’re going full Brindy. When I said what I said about Laughton it was under the assumption that Staal was getting signed and was going to be here. I’ve always assumed that. My idea of we should build the team that Rod wants always had Staal in it for this coming year.
I think you’ve heard me enough over the years say I’m not the biggest Staal fan, though I enjoy him much more once he became the 3C. Signing him at this point for four years to me is in a giggly sort of way “gross”. I don’t mind the money, which I said. The contract and cap hit aspect doesn’t bother me at all. I was just fine moving on from him either now or maybe next year.
I don’t see Staal as an aggressive player, he’s always been a bit of a gentle giant. He’s a moose though, contact comes to him constantly and bounces off. He could use a few more guys in support of the style that have the skill level to make us better within the style.
My point is 2 fold. 1) what you described for Laughton: "A hard working grinder that can score a bit and is a good character guy" is a very apt description for Jordan Staal.
2) Whether he's "more aggressive" or "goes to the net more", it hasn't resulted in tangibly scoring more goals/points/driving more offense. Laughton hasn't outscored Fast 5v5 the last 3 years and BARELY outscored Martinook. Granted, there could be a team component to it.
I do think he'd be an upgrade over Martinook on Staal's line so I'm with you there. I just think there are a lot of plug and play players that would excel on that line with Staal so I'm not sure spending a bunch on a guy who just had a career year makes sense vs. addressing other scoring needs upfront. I won't be disappointed if we got him though.
EDIT: Actually my point was 3 fold. I couldn't resist poking fun at you using your own words.