The comparison of Paul vs Joseph is natural since we traded one for the other, but it does feel at times that people are taking the best Paul has to offer and comparing it to the worst of Joseph.
Joseph certainly struggled this year, playing with Motte, Pinto, Gambrell, Brassard. None of them are good enough to carry a line, and only Pinto belongs on a third line.
When did Paul ever have linemates like that,
2018-19 and 19-20: Brown, Pageau
20-21: White, Dadonov
21-22: Brown, Sandford, Stützle
22-23: Kilorn, Colton, Stamkos
Both guys are complimentary pieces, Paul a physical defensive minded guy that can open up the ice for skilled linemates and cover up for them defensively while chipping in with some greasy goals, Joseph a speedster that can spread out the D and and force rushed decisions on the forcheck. Joseph had a poor season, no doubt, but he was also put in a position that didn't really gel with what he provides.
I like Paul more because of his versatility, he can still be an effective grinder if he doesn't have the linemates where as Joseph is more of a pure support role guy, but I didn't see us use Joseph in a way where we could get theost out of him. I think he's going to have a bounce back year if he's playing with Pinto and Greig all year.