**I agree with the overall opinion - they need more skill, so this is just a nuanced discussion.**
I guess it depends on what your definition of elite talent is, but I firmly believe that TK is an elite winger. His tracking data is below - according to all three zones tracking, he's in the 95th (or better) percentile for shots, shot assists, primary contributions, chance contributions, chance assists, high danger assists, one-timer assists, cycle & forecheck offense, rush offense, entries with chances, and controlled entries with chances.
He's also 26th of 354 forwards (500m) in ES xGAR Offense, and 29th of 354 in ES GAR offense.
Again, I'm not saying this to be decisive, but I don't know if TK gets enough credit for how good of a player his is. I've been saying this since last year, but with a legitimate 1C, not even an elite 1C, someone like Eriksson Ek, he's a 90 point player IMO.
What does he look like in TOR instead of Marner, for example? I'm not saying he's as good as Marner, but it's pretty clear that Marner and Matthews benefit from playing with each other. It would be nice to see prime TK with a real 1C.
View attachment 836418