I don't think this poll is close enough to accurate. Several misses, no goalies...
The way to do these comparisons is also to compare positions, playing style and/or role importance (best C vs best C, Top Winger vs Top Winger, Top pairing D-man vs Top pairing D-man, etc)
Stützle vs Suzuki : Suzuki was great last season and better than Stu but the guy had a 90 pts season at 20 y/o, he's just scratching the surface.
Tkachuk vs Slafkovsky : This would have been laughable 6 months ago but Slaf will actually make it interesting
Batherson vs Caufield : it should be Caufield because of his goal scoring talent but if he's not scoring 40+, I take Drake without thinking
Norris vs Dach : whoever ends up more healthy? Goal scoring 2-way center vs Playmaking 2-way center. 2 very nice young talents who have been derailed by injuries. Norris is more proven though, scored 47 goals in 91 games before he ran into injury trouble. He was 21-22 y/o
Pinto vs Newhook : Pinto should run away with this with his rapidly evolving 2-way game but you never know, they are still only 23 y/o
Greig vs Roy : 2 very intriguing young players, Greig is already top notch defensively, Roy should be more productive. If they produce similar offense then it's Greig easily
Joseph vs Evans : 2 very interesting and speedy bottom-6 forwards. I'd take Joseph who is a PK beast and more proven too
Halliday, Ostapchuk, Jarventie vs Beck, Mesar, Farrell : Montreal has more than that in terms of forward prospects (Heineman, Kidney, etc), Ottawa not much after these 3 since Dorion botched the last 3 drafts (traded high picks, picking Tyler Boucher 10th OA, etc)
Chabot vs Guhle : not exactly the same style but still remember that guy on another site who was insulting me because I didn't agree with "Guhle is already better"
Sanderson vs Hutson : Hutson will have to hit significantly to be as good as Jake who is going among the NHL Elite for a long time.
Chychrun vs Mailloux : Chychrun was disappointing last season (despite 41 pts) but Mailloux would have to hit significantly to be as good.
Zub vs Reinbacher : Reinbacher could end up quite better but Zub is a great defensive D-man so will have to wait on that one as well.
Kleven vs Xhekaj : Xhekaj is more proven but blows defensively, Kleven should be quite better
Brännström vs Struble : 2 very reliable #5 D-men. Struble is a great athlete, Branchise is excellent in transition, very smart.
Bernard-Docker vs Harris : pure defensive D-man vs puck mover, hard to say who's going to be better. I think Harris is a bit more valuable although JBD is good at "survival defense", reminds me of Josh Gorges a bit but not as good as of now.
Guénette, Donovan, Andonovski vs Barron, Engstrom, Trudeau : Same as with forwards, Montreal restocked the last few drafts, Ottawa not so much
Sogaard, Merilainen, Reidler vs Fowler, Primeau, Dobes : this is going to be quite interesting. Fowler is the best prospect here and Montreal has a much better track record at developing goalies but who the hell knows here?
Now, that comparison would have been ridiculous to make just 2-3 years ago but Montreal fixed their management and coaching way earlier than Ottawa did (with Melnyk passing, it took a while for the team to be sold), as they were stuck with Pierre Dorion who was so inept that Montreal GAINED a lot of ground in the last 2 seasons. It is still clearly Ottawa but it's getting closer and closer. Not only Dorion was inept but he was actually a self sabotaging GM who has hurt the rebuild A LOT, the worst GM in NHL history IMO. I started a comparison with Milbury but I stopped as I don't see how it's even going to be close. Dorion had absolutely no business being a NHL GM.
Hard to say what will happen with Ottawa going forward, Staois and Green are new on the job, as well as many other people hired recently. The Melnyk-Dorion reign of terror has finally ended and it takes a while to recover from that. It starts with the 2024 draft in 11 days. They need a great draft to stop Montreal from gaining ground. Montreal has 5th OA and 26th OA while Ottawa has 7th OA and 25th OA.
I would LIKE to hear arguments from people voting Montreal here. Sure Ottawa didn't do a lot better the last 3 seasons in terms of team results but there's still a vast difference in terms of talent and it was very apparent when the teams faced each others.