Value of: Sean Monahan to Winnipeg
- Thread starter DudeWhereIsMakar
- Start date
- Status
Toninado and Stanley have no value to Montreal.
Seems very unlikely Monahan gets traded for anything less than a 1st+ given his strong play, his public desire to be in Montreal and Mtl's injury depleted roster.
1st, Kupari, Barron might get Hughes to listen, if that seems to much then the Jets are probably shopping elsewhere
FerrisRox
"Wanna go, Prettyboy?"
Montreal would have no interest at all in acquiring a defensemen and I'm assuming Toninado is there to send a centre back to finish the season, so this is basically a 2nd rounder for Monahan which is probably about right, but I suspect the Canadiens could get a 2nd rounder and some kind of project prospect or younger player they like tossed in from someone if they wait closer to the deadline when prices start to rise.
Tasteless Beaver
Here for the hot takes
No need to pay for him as a rental, we'll just wait and sign him for free in the off-season.
Y'all are something else lmao
Fatass
Registered User
- Apr 17, 2017
- 23,860
- 15,519
Sorry Habs’ fans but Monahan isn’t worth a whole heck of a lot. He’s older and injury prone. Too big a risk for playoff clubs to offer up too much. Habs should, of course, trade this plsyer and get the third rounder he will return, as they aren’t going to the playoffs this year.
MardyBum
Registered User
Monahan is only an upgrade on Namestnikov on faceoffs, why are we paying assets for a 3C to replace a guy who shouldn't be playing 2C anyways? Aim higher.
I can't say, haven't seen much of the Jets/Namestnikov. Monahan is being used in a much bigger role (~3min/game more) and with far less top 6 talent. A GM/pro scout might well view Monahan as able to contribute more in the Jets roster context.
If the Jets are 100% all in this year trading for Monaghan would mean the Jets are only 5% in.
JetsFan815
Replacement Level Poster
- Jan 16, 2012
- 19,666
- 25,699
This is an overpayment. The ceiling on the return on Monahan is the Domi trade last year and I doubt it even fetches that considering Domi had better numbers and was injury free and even Domi only went for a late 2nd. No way the Jets should be trading the Habs 2nd round pick for Monahan which is very likely going to be a top-40 pick.
Davo Ikinzom
Registered User
I'm not impressed by Monahan, and don't think he fits the Jets' style very well. They play a very fast, aggressive style, and Monahan is not a high-pace player. In any case, I don't think he'd be more effective than Namestnikov, who cost the Jets a 4th at last year's deadline. Jets should be aiming higher at this TDL.
cheechoo
Lilje 4-ever
Haven't seen much of Monahan this season, but his game historically has never impressed me. Soft, not a great defensive game, not much of a line driver.
Faceoff ace(?), very good hands and in front of the net as the bumper on the powerplay.
Multitude of injuries later and more miles on that body, is he a playoff caliber checking center? I don't see it.
An older Jeff Carter like goal scoring winger type and I can see the utility, playing alongside a playdriver.
Faceoff ace(?), very good hands and in front of the net as the bumper on the powerplay.
Multitude of injuries later and more miles on that body, is he a playoff caliber checking center? I don't see it.
An older Jeff Carter like goal scoring winger type and I can see the utility, playing alongside a playdriver.
Fatass
Registered User
- Apr 17, 2017
- 23,860
- 15,519
That’s about right for Monahan. He’s not a key piece.
yup. every single deadline... it's called a historical record
Every single time
blankall
Registered User
- Jul 4, 2007
- 15,110
- 5,520
Monahan is on pace for less than fifty points while getting top six minutes. When Calgary moved Monahan into a bottom six role, he was useless. He's not the best skater, isn't physical, and is not great defensively.
I don't see Monahan as the type of player teams will look to attain for a playoff run. A guy like Domi had lots of jam, which Monahan doesn't have.
I don't see Monahan as the type of player teams will look to attain for a playoff run. A guy like Domi had lots of jam, which Monahan doesn't have.
Not a terrible offer. Hughes would probably fish around to try to get a first for him but if no one bites then sure. I would prefer a 2nd + a body/contract F that ends at the end of the season to balance out money. No need for yet another D.
Coffee
Take one step towards the direction you want to go
- Nov 12, 2021
- 9,128
- 7,979
SlafySZN
Registered User
- May 21, 2022
- 7,498
- 16,206
He plays with Jake Evans and Gallagher… don’t know where you want the 50 points to come from.
The Jets need a 2C, not a 4C . No interest from Winnipeg.
Antiillafire
Registered User
The 2 players in the deal have no value to Montreal so it essentially boils down to the second rounder in a down draft depth wise.
Stanley only has value to Montreal if a nuclear bomb explodes in Laval and Montreal. The forward is a guy who will take up spots for Montreal’s young prospects in Laval or will be a useless 4th liner
Stanley only has value to Montreal if a nuclear bomb explodes in Laval and Montreal. The forward is a guy who will take up spots for Montreal’s young prospects in Laval or will be a useless 4th liner
gojetsgo
Registered User
- Nov 1, 2015
- 11,146
- 31,317
no interest in monahan, if the jets go after somebody it should be a legit 2c
Domi is soft as butter except when he occasionally sucker punch someone (that isn't really a positive attribute...). He sure brings more speed, but he Monahan is a better center and defensive player. My opinion is mostly based on both players tenure in Montreal. Doesn't seem like Domi changed a ton from my viewings this season either ...
- Status
