This might be a long one so I apologize in advance lol..
This is definitely a mix of almost everything. They don't have elite veterans. They are solid, but not elite. Neither can carry a line or put the team on their back & with so many young guys there are games (like vs Brampton) where it kills you. Wainwright is their only F who sometimes can takeover a game or will the team to a W, but it has been more hit or miss than id like.
Fischer's injury was absolutely crippling to this team. I knew it would be bad, but in that time we saw Hurt & Barr play the worst hockey they've played in the OHL & both have 0 confidence right now. Bodin very clearly needs Fischer as his partner to be his best. Just has to defend. If he's asked to do more he struggles. Young & Bridegwater really stepped up imo, but that couldn't overcome the rest falling apart.
Brown has definitely disappointed. His play hasn't been anywhere as strong as we saw in glimpses last yr, or in camp/pre season & when he has played well he's gotten zero luck. Been a season from hell for him so far. Kostuch had mono & that clearly took a toll until id say the last 3 weeks where he's looked significantly better. Karimov definitely isn't as good as some pegged him. Some services had him as a 1st round pick.. He certainly isn't that & I say that as a big fan of his game. I think he'll be a damn good OHLer at 18&19, but clearly he was a bit overhyped/he dominated a much weaker league. That's 3 guys we all hoped could be 20-25G, 50+ point players & right now there's a chance none of them hit 20Gs or 40 points..
I don't think its entirely their fault & I'm not giving up on them as guys who will be great players for us next yr & beyond. Letang hasn't given Kostuch any PP time & no OT time. Karimov was buried on L4 for a month & seemingly isn't allowed to go more than 2-3 games without being demoted no matter how good he does. Brown has been given the ice time, but he hasn't been paired with a vet C all yr. He was trying to do way to much w/Di iorio as his C & he had 0 chemistry with Johnston. Mind boggling he hasn't been stapled next to wainwright after the chemistry those 2 had last yr.
Johnston started great & it looked like Seca found another hidden gem, but for the first time when trying to find someone needing more ice he missed. The kid sadly is soft as hot butter & it's only gotten worse. He's become a full on a liability & Letang only now has started benching him. He also seems incredibly hard to play with. The young guys especially have had 0 offence playing with him. Not a coincidence to me our F lines looked the best vs BRMP.. with him not playing.
While I like their energy & u do need some sand paper, Franceschetti & Moses have brought absolutely nothing to the table offensively & as of late neither is even stirring the pot or fighting which is their role on the team. Luecke was providing no offence & neither was Sim. 2nd yr in a row the 4th line is bringing 0 production to this team & that hurts.
Special teams have been the worst in the league & it isn't remotely close the past 15-18 games. This team doesn't have the offensive firepower to withstand a power play being this goddamn bad. They'd have 3or4 more wins if the PP was just 17% which still isn't good & how different would this season feel just from that? The PK was so good at the start but once Fischer went down it went right to hell & they've been unable to stop the bleeding.
I think Letang has done them a major disservice with the constant line changes. They have very rarely looked in sync as a F unit this season. We are 25 games in. That is unacceptable & borderline unfathomable. The last thing a group of rookies & young kids need is confusion on the ice & that's what it looks like they are so often lately. Confused. They don't know where to be or where there line mates will be. especially when they have a couple guys id say are a bit difficult to play with in Wainwright, Johnson, Karimov & Brown. all 4 love to hold onto the puck for too long & at times don't use their line mates nearly enough. So trying to play off them when u don't have a ton of reps is difficult & leads to confusion/lack of chemistry..
I think we all agree there assistants seemingly provide nothing to this team & that helps no one it actually hurts everyone. The players, Letang, special teams etc. Neither has experience to calm these kids down or direct them in the right direction or adjust stuff on the PP/PK etc. I cant imagine the players look back at them on the bench in anticipation of some good advice & with such a young team they sure could use someone who could do those things.
They've had a pretty hard schedule & we've probably under sold it at times recently with our bitterness, frustration. They've played 9 games vs teams not considered all that good/not going for it (SSM/SBY/NB/OS/FLT/OTT) & they've gone 6-1-3.. Flip side they've played 18 games vs teams many consider elite/cup contenders (LDN/WSR/SAG/BRNT/BRMP/NIA/OSH/BAR/KIT/ER) & in those 18 they've gone 2-14-2... A lot of that during the 8 game trip with Fischer, Bodin hurt, Di Iorio, Edwards gone & Wainwright SSPD 3 games.
Issue is now the wheels have come off. They look defeated & lost. This many young guys & they've likely never gone thru a stretch this awful or felt this outclassed. I don't feel the coaching has helped at all & I do think we can maybe question the leadership. Fischer finally comes back & now he's gone again after doing a stupid, selfish gesture. Wainwright isn't a vocal guy its a more follow me type thing & he's been really quiet lately. Doucette isn't a very vocal or gritty player, especially for an OA. Two of the assistants are 17 yr olds in Hurt & Brown who are now going thru it. So who the heck is gonna standup between periods, or during a period & say wake the F up or this isn't acceptable etc? That is lacking it seems.
Say all that to say, this team has had about every single thing go wrong for them the last 15-18 games. It's pretty remarkable & now it's gotten into there heads & if they cant fix it quickly this could get way out of hand. If you've made to the end of my novel congratulations lmao.