I'd be with you if I had great confidence in the '04 or '05 class. the 2004 class (Sinclair's last draft) was/is a full fledged disaster. Namestnikov 3rd overall = didn't live up. Morden 2nd round = didn't report. McIntyre 3rd round = Didn't develop. Casey 4th round = didn't come. Eveleigh 5th round = didn't develop. Filak, Harper & Grover are the only guys we have left from that draft.
The '05 class (covid year so I cut some slack was crapshoot) has some good players in MacDonell, Daviault, Wainwright, but they didn't get much else. Lalkin in the 2nd sucked, Tierman hasn't shown anything, Perreault going NCAA, Degelas still a work in progress, Thomas NCAA.
I just don't have as much confidence in that group as I do in Voit, Burke, Mast, Gaudreau, Vilmanis, Lantz, Dillingham, Ritchie & now Pastujov.
You're right though that they don't have overly enticing pieces to sell next year to recoup picks. Be Romeo, Sikic, Vilmanis & maybe 19 year olds like Filak & Hoover. They'll get back two 2nds, two 3rds, 4th & 5th from the Moldenhaur trade + we still currently have three 2nds, 3rd, four 4ths, three 5ths. Don't think we'll use all of it so it's not like we have nothing.
For me you go for it now then next year it's all about ice time for Martone, Fischer, Doherty, Campbell, Chartier, Hall, Young along with their 1st rounder in the upcoming draft & whoever else makes the team or surprises while guys like MacDonell, Daviault, Wainwright, Filak, Hoover take that next step as veterans.
Then the following year your fairly competitive as the '06 class is 18, '05 class is 19, Filak hopefully a solid OA & whoever we take this yr is 17. Then that next year (I know im getting so far ahead) if they aren't in the pros, MacDonell, Daviault are stud OAs, Martone is an absolute animal as a 19 yr old (if he's back) & hopefully the other '06s I've mentioned also take good steps & are legitimate impactful players at 19. Then you have a strong core with 9-10-11-12 guys who've been around awhile along with whoever else we draft in the next 2 years in the O draft & import draft & whoever we add via trade in the coming seasons.
Understand your reservations, especially with this team/org. If (and probably when) they choke this April it's gonna make it worse knowing the next few years won't be overly exciting but god damnit it's been to long & this was the time iMO.
Just how I see it. Sorry for the novel haha.