Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Oh hey, you DID re-read the thread. Maybe not the part about how the stats show Joey isn't a #1 C this season but that's ok.
If we go by only what folks have shown this season, there isn't a single NHL-quality anyone (at their present positions) on the roster or in this front office save maybe Boone Jenner, and we therefore need to trash or demote everybody. Singling out Johansen is absurd.
Fine, ditch the Stamkos comparison. $7 million AAV (which is what Overhardt initially wanted) of last year's $69 million cap is comparable to when Patrick Kane signed his 5 year/$31.5 million deal in terms of percentage of cap.
Hmm. A young, flashy All-Star scorer coming off of a career high season, with occasional attitude issues, and who thus serves as top-quality skill but ultimately structurally kind of supporting cast to mentally stronger but less productive leader types. Sounds like an excellent comparable to me.
Of course, Kane's career high season was definitely better than Johansen's, but that's why it's an initial ask rather than a final contract.