Toggle sidebar

Injury Report: Ryan Callahan (2/5: Wearing full contact jersey in practice)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Kershaw
  • Start date Start date
The way it's being talked about in here, if you didn't see it you'd think he'd been stretchered off the ice...
 
Fire Sather said:
You can be positive all you want, it looked bad, we lost depth in the Nash trade and now Cally goes down..

team is farther and farther away from last year
Click to expand...

It couldnt look good since he went right off the ice but he didnt fall on his shoulder it looked like it popped out after being tugged on. We have no idea how bad it is but it could be ok. Lets wait and see
 
RGY said:
:laugh: ooook Mr. Cynical. Watch the replay. During the sequence you see Callahan mouthing something right before he goes to the ice as if to tell talbot to let up. Talbot does. When callahan goes down, Talbot looks over him almost in a confused way, mouths something to him, and callahan responds with something. I don't think there was intent at all. Talbot is not a dirty player.
Click to expand...

you watch what he does to his arm. you tell me that doesn't look intentional. he throws his entire weight into cally's chest while he pulls the arm away. i don't care what you "think" you saw them say(i could say the sky is falling, doesn't mean it's happening)-- what talbot did was NOT something that happens in a scrum or a fight. that was a very specific action with a pretty straightforward(potential) consequence.

and for those of you saying "OH HE LET UP, IT WAS CLEAN PLAY BRO"--the job was done. what point would there be to stay at it?
 
mooskating said:
headhunting at it's finest. nice job talbot smh. he threw his WHOLE weight of his body into dislocating cally's shoulder. no way in hell was that a punch. rewatch the video. that was an intentional dislocation. he puts one arm on the shoulder and pulls while he pushes all of his body into the chest. intentional 100%. talbot's reaction afterwards says it all
Click to expand...

lolwut.
 
mooskating said:
headhunting at it's finest. nice job talbot smh. he threw his WHOLE weight of his body into dislocating cally's shoulder. no way in hell was that a punch. rewatch the video. that was an intentional dislocation. he puts one arm on the shoulder and pulls while he pushes all of his body into the chest. intentional 100%. talbot's reaction afterwards says it all
Click to expand...

I'm happy I'm not the only one that thinks that was a chicken**** move by Talbot.

That said, I Eat Crow, RN believes it's a dislocated shoulder for Callahan. The way he was walking off the ice looks to me that the left shoulder was out of the socket. Fingers crossed that the trainers are able to pop it back into place and he missed only 2-4 weeks. Callahan is a tough SOB, if no surgery is required, I can see him back in a few days.
 
li97 said:
You CAN NOT dislocate your shoulder and not tear your labrum. If your labrum doesnt tear your shoulder will not pop out. I had the surgery done by a surgeon who works on isles and jets shoulders.

That said, he might be able to put surgery off until the off season but it would probably just keep popping ut again, especially with his style of play.
Click to expand...

this. not trying to play doctor and not a doom and gloom guy, just something I've dealt with myself for four years. hoping for the best for cally but ive never been the same since, that being said I don't have my own surgeon and training staff
 
I'll have to look at it again but my immediate reaction would have to be that its highly unlikely.
 
mooskating said:
you watch what he does to his arm. you tell me that doesn't look intentional. he throws his entire weight into cally's chest while he pulls the arm away. i don't care what you "think" you saw them say(i could say the sky is falling, doesn't mean it's happening)-- what talbot did was NOT ng that happens in a scrum or a fight. that was a very specific action with a pretty ightforward(potential) consequence.

and for those of you saying "OH HE LET UP, IT WAS CLEAN PLAY BRO"--the job was done. what point would there be to stay at it?
Click to expand...

Talbot isn't a dirty player. You're making him sound like a hitman. Where are you getting this nonsense?
 
li97 said:
You CAN NOT dislocate your shoulder and not tear your labrum. If your labrum doesnt tear your shoulder will not pop out. I had the surgery done by a surgeon who works on isles and jets shoulders.

That said, he might be able to put surgery off until the off season but it would probably just keep popping ut again, especially with his style of play.
Click to expand...

This is not accurate. Its not a 100% certainty.

A dislocation will often lead to laxity of the shoulder.. Even without tearing. This means recurrence of injury and dislocation in the future which can certainly lead to labrum injury down the line.

Again, let's not jump off the bridge yet.
 
Why is an injury suddenly a poll for how many weeks of MIA?
It's a bit silly. It's like guessing how long it'll take for the pizza to arrive.
 
mooskating said:
you watch what he does to his arm. you tell me that doesn't look intentional. he throws his entire weight into cally's chest while he pulls the arm away. i don't care what you "think" you saw them say(i could say the sky is falling, doesn't mean it's happening)-- what talbot did was NOT something that happens in a scrum or a fight. that was a very specific action with a pretty straightforward(potential) consequence.

and for those of you saying "OH HE LET UP, IT WAS CLEAN PLAY BRO"--the job was done. what point would there be to stay at it?
Click to expand...

Huh? :shakehead Oh that;s right they were talking crap to each other the entire time. You sound ridiculous right now. Talbot is not a dirty player, he isn't. It turned into a fight. He was pushing and pulling on callahan just like a lot of fights go. This isn't Tie Domi spinning guys around. Players jerk each other for leverage. Colton Orr did it to Todd Fedoruk when he knocked him out. Cut the bs out. Talbot showed respect and that is that.
 
nyr2k2 said:
Talbot isn't a dirty player. You're making him sound like a hitman. Where are you getting this nonsense?
Click to expand...

watched it for at least 5 minutes from multiple angles. i'm pretty confident that this is not a punch. i don't care if he's been a clean player his entire career-- this is a questionable move. he didn't just punch him in the shoulder, he grabbed his arm and threw his body against his chest as hard as he could.

a player doesn't have to be dirty to do something dirty-- there are plenty of dirty hits by clean players. i strongly believe this is one of those dirty moves, and honestly i can't see any logical way to think of this as a clean or 'accidental' play.
 
mooskating said:
watched it for at least 5 minutes from multiple angles. i'm pretty confident that this is not a punch. i don't care if he's been a clean player his entire career-- this is a questionable move. he didn't just punch him in the shoulder, he grabbed his arm and threw his body against his chest as hard as he could.
Click to expand...

It's not questionable at all, IMO. Talbot did nothing wrong.
 
mooskating said:
watched it for at least 5 minutes from multiple angles. i'm pretty confident that this is not a punch. i don't care if he's been a clean player his entire career-- this is a questionable move. he didn't just punch him in the shoulder, he grabbed his arm and threw his body against his chest as hard as he could.

a player doesn't have to be dirty to do something dirty-- there are plenty of dirty hits by clean players. i strongly believe this is one of those dirty moves, and honestly i can't see any logical way to think of this as a clean or 'accidental' play.
Click to expand...

It was a fight, guys tug and pull on each other. It didn't look intentional at all.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom