Do players/prospects for SKA get the same level of hate as CSKA?
And this is also a generalization. Of course some fans of the teams those players played before SKA dislike their decision.
What is real is the disliking for SKA in general, not for particular players. Even the haters' narrative would be "SKA ruins those talented young players", which is of course not true too, but who cares among haters?
The hate for SKA is just potentiated by the persona of Rotenberg Jr. . Every rich team is hated for being rich and able to lure away players. So SKA and CSKA alike, but then SKA has Rotenberg who also happens to be the real no.1 of the FHR while Tretiak is just acting gramps. So far Rotenberg's strategies are a lot of talk and a lot less results.