Speculation: Roster Building Thread: Part XIV (To trade or not to trade is the question)

zlev

Registered User
Dec 21, 2015
2,154
4,212
they're going to fire the coach and then play way better. bookmark this post.

I'm convinced fans that want Torts don't remember 2013. It wasn't that much worse than this version until they made a couple of smart moves at the deadline. That team hovered around .500 for the longest time and didn't play all that hard.

Torts was/is a jackass and a moron. and a terrible coach. he was throwing his own players under the bus in the post game press conferences during that season. he's just a profoundly dumb guy that yells a lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nsvoyageurs

duhmetreE

Blessed Bigly
Sponsor
Jan 18, 2012
34,724
52,815
they're going to fire the coach and then play way better. bookmark this post.
The problem isn’t them playing better. At this point, it’s nearly impossible not to play better.

Are they good enough to win? That’s a resounding, no. We all knew it going into the season.

Drury failed miserably in the offseason.

Lavi failed miserably with system changes

The players are failing miserably at a level I haven’t seen before.
 

smoneil

Registered User
Jul 14, 2004
5,944
5,114
Rochester, NY
No for a # of reasons, but the biggest is to break Zib
ck plays, zib sits every fuggin game his back is up for it

break Mika break
Lindy should not wait, deall immediately

then we see...

Bern, you're saying no for one reason and one reason only. Kreider is your favorite player. I get it. The team has traded every one of my favorite players. But you have to look at it objectively. He's a big presence in a room that isn't working. His production is way down. His speed is slowing down. His replacement is already on the team. He's still worth some value in trade. His cap space can be better spent elsewhere. And, to your point, moving him is the BEST way to break Mika out of his funk.

In a perfect world, we'd be able to let Kreider be a career Ranger. Teams don't get embarrassed night after night in a perfect world. It's time to move Kreider.
 

CLW

Registered User
Nov 11, 2018
7,422
7,251
The problem isn’t them playing better. At this point, it’s nearly impossible not to play better.

Are they good enough to win? That’s a resounding, no. We all knew it going into the season.

Drury failed miserably in the offseason.

Lavi failed miserably with system changes

The players are failing miserably at a level I haven’t seen before.

What is both strange and fascinating is how clueless management and coaches are how to fix their mistakes. Trust and respect has obviously broken down across the lines. Doing nothing fixes nothing. Your move Mr. President GM.

I started following this team with an interest when the rebuild started. I've always rooted for the kids. I've always said that pandering to the country club click is ruining the team. I've always said that integrating the kids is crucial.

Now here we are looking at the shipwreck of a rebuild. Good job Drury.
 

surlysailor

Registered User
May 12, 2012
698
405
BK
I hate to move on from kreider but it’s time. I think they should look to a team like LA. They have a bunch of prospects who would be closer to nhl ready compared to a late 1st. Maybe some assortment like of greentree, Hughes, kaliyev, or some other playoff team that has closer to ready prospects. Tho lak is not a good example but a team deep in d prospects would be ideal. I’d also call up syky, maybe he’s not ready but he seems like an infectious guy that can amp up the players around him like berard does.
 

EdJovanovski

#RempeForCalder
Apr 26, 2016
30,232
60,938
The Rempire State
What?

Schaefer is f***ing fire.
Is it even unanimous? Definitely seems to be one of the lesser hyped drafts in recent memory. Ironically Laf was one of the most hyped, and Kakko vs Hughes were too. On the bright side as those show us, it’s never a sure thing. Celebrini is outperforming Bedard who had way more hype. You never know
 

GoAwayPanarin

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
May 27, 2008
44,495
58,029
In High Altitoad
Is it even unanimous? Definitely seems to be one of the lesser hyped drafts in recent memory. Ironically Laf was one of the most hyped, and Kakko vs Hughes were too. On the bright side as those show us, it’s never a sure thing. Celebrini is outperforming Bedard who had way more hype. You never know

No it’s not but it’ll be more lopsided by the time the final rankings come out. Hagens is very good and we should all be very happy if by some miracle the Rangers were able to get him but Schaefer is phenomenal.

Also lol at you now pumping Celebrini.
 

FoxysExpensiveNYDigs

Boo Nieves Truther
Feb 27, 2002
6,576
4,167
Colorado
Bern, you're saying no for one reason and one reason only. Kreider is your favorite player. I get it. The team has traded every one of my favorite players. But you have to look at it objectively. He's a big presence in a room that isn't working. His production is way down. His speed is slowing down. His replacement is already on the team. He's still worth some value in trade. His cap space can be better spent elsewhere. And, to your point, moving him is the BEST way to break Mika out of his funk.

In a perfect world, we'd be able to let Kreider be a career Ranger. Teams don't get embarrassed night after night in a perfect world. It's time to move Kreider.
Amazing how it's everyone else's fault but Kreider eh? 😅
 

duhmetreE

Blessed Bigly
Sponsor
Jan 18, 2012
34,724
52,815
I’m honestly content with selling off and retooling.

Let the kids get time. Hopefully get a good pick. Hopefully get some nice returns for whatever vets were can unload…, even if it’s just Kreider and Lindgren.

Get some cheap replacement level defenders to finish the year. Move Mika to RW. Make him uncomfortable hopefully he waives.
 

WojtekWolski86

Registered User
Nov 14, 2019
2,869
4,701
Figures the year we suck ass the projected top pick is mid.


But who any kidding Drury will probably trade our first for Granlund or something anyway
We will make that top pick look mid for 5 years. Make them "play the right way" by giving them 4th line minutes or healthy scratching instead of letting them develop in Jr. or college.
 

Synergy27

F-A-C-G-C-E
Apr 27, 2004
13,908
13,066
Washington, D.C.
I don’t think this will ever happen because the dude sells tickets, but if Panarin is of interest to any contenders, I pull the trigger and take the assets. I think the freewheeling style and lack of defense we see from a lot of the forwards starts with Panarin, who is really the only player we have that is talented enough to play the way he does. Trading him both resets the culture and theoretically brings back a haul, especially if retained.

The Caps seems like they have a legit chance this year. Do you think they listen on a package involving Panarin for Leonard?
 

WojtekWolski86

Registered User
Nov 14, 2019
2,869
4,701
I’m honestly content with selling off and retooling.

Let the kids get time. Hopefully get a good pick. Hopefully get some nice returns for whatever vets were can unload…, even if it’s just Kreider and Lindgren.

Get some cheap replacement level defenders to finish the year. Move Mika to RW. Make him uncomfortable hopefully he waives.
I'd move Mika to RW to at least get his head out of his ass. He looks lost in this defensive scheme. Maybe he can find his offensive game again from the wing.

Second piece of change that NEEDS to happen is breaking up PP1. If we are truly transitioning then staying with a stale 4 yr old unit that is no longer dominant makes zero sense. Move Laf up and see what he's got on that unit.
 

Levitate

Registered User
Jul 29, 2004
31,501
8,934
I don’t think Lavi is a good coach, but I don’t think he’s anywhere near the heart of THE problem at this point. Why he loses teams is irrelevant, IMO. All coaches lose their teams. Most teams have a new coach every 3-5 years. The question isn’t why Lavi loses teams. The question is why THIS team has quit on 3 straight coaches in 5 years. I don’t care who the coach is at that point; it could be Dancing Larry and he could be drunk every game/practice and exclusively talk to the players in pig Latin and I would still be completely incapable of siding with the players on this one. They’re an entitled group of babies who quit on every coach they have.

And the thing is, WE are sitting here saying Lavi needs to go because he doesn’t change up the top PP or break up Kreider and Zib or stop giving Lindgren big minutes… well, what are the players quitting for than? He’s basically doing what THEY want him to do. We want Zib sitting a game. We want Kreider benched. We want vets losing their spots to kids on the PP. We want Lindgren on the bottom pair. If Lavi did all of those things, could you imagine the amount of tears there would be in that locker room? Mika would flood the Garden. So what are they even quitting on? They’re not even being shown tough love.

They’re quitting because they’re gutless pansies who wilt when facing adversity and have been enjoying the scent of their own flatulence for far too long while being absolutely pampered in every way by this organization, it’s media and the multiple coaches they’ve had the privilege of quitting on. I don’t care if you were Al Arbour, Stan Bowman, Joel Quennville, Spencer Carberry… it does not matter. These boys are only going to work hard for you for about 16 months and if they don’t win the Cup that year, you might as well just resign and let them move on to the next coach.

It’s time to break up the band. They haven’t released an album in years and they keep touring, playing songs that used to be hits but they have no energy anymore and the singer’s voice is shot.
This guy gets it
 

lakeshirts37

Registered User
Jun 25, 2019
1,242
1,303
Figures the year we suck ass the projected top pick is mid.


But who any kidding Drury will probably trade our first for Granlund or something anyway
Well we had back to back cant miss prospects in the top2 and you know how that worked out. Im done trying to project these kids
 

UAGoalieGuy

Registered User
Dec 29, 2005
16,451
4,492
Richmond, VA
No it’s not but it’ll be more lopsided by the time the final rankings come out. Hagens is very good and we should all be very happy if by some miracle the Rangers were able to get him but Schaefer is phenomenal.

Also lol at you now pumping Celebrini.

Rangers honestly couldn't go wrong if they somehow got a top 3 pick. The top 3 is pretty much set unless someone gets hurt or does terribly in the WJC. Each plays a position of need.

Hagens (Center)
Schaefer (Left Defense)
Martone (Right Wing)
 

Shesterkybomb

Registered User
Dec 30, 2016
16,968
18,334
bold = no, that makes YOU feel good, it does not generate desired results

coupla these players are salvageable w/youth
REST OF THE VETS HAVE GOT TO GO
whether addition by subtraction or sell high

truth is, keeping these players gonna mostly = more of the same
their talent level, for the most part is not there
Admit this fact so you can proceed properly
Nope that's not it at all. Management and coaching staff have lost a eastern conference finals team in a matter of months and now they are competing with the worst in the league. We were a contender this year until the puck dropped, it's management, it's coaching and it's lack of effort from the players, all of it is tied together.

what’s a Coyle, Frederic package look like ?
Why? We need more guys who can't put the puck in the net?
 

Barnaby

Registered User
Jul 2, 2003
8,830
3,656
Port Jefferson, NY
K
I don’t see the reason to trade Kakko or KAM, unless it’s a package consolidated for an upgrade.

They’re controllable. They fill their role. They’re not going to be “the guy” but they still young and there’s still potential there in a better environment.

It’s hard to evaluate when everyone is sucking. Once again, I’d keep all RFAs unless an upgrade is available
Kakko and KAM the vanilla twins who will want significant raises…..
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad