This is really looking at everything in a vacuum. We have covered this quite a bit, especially Edge.
While it may not turn out this way, Tony D had his breakout season last year. He is 8 months older. Who is to say Bennett wont breakout this year or next? And maybe the change of scenery would help him thrive. Regardless he plays a physical game. He can provide insurance at Center even if we played him predominately at wing. He has been good in the playoffs. He is a gamer. This would be a good depth addition for a team that needs more depth.
Plus we don’t have room for more high end offensive players, besides maybe a 2C if Chytil doesn’t pan out. We need to build a better, more stable bottom six. The guys there are doing well this year but they’re tweeners. Barron, Bennett, Berard would potentially be a really nice third line one day, and the kind of bottom six depth you want in the playoffs.