I don’t agree with everything here but you earned a like because it’s a well thought out post. I’m not arguing Quinn was a great coach or that he was the primary reason behind that team being more exciting, but several of our guys did have their best seasons under him. I did like the construction of that team better, obviously it was a younger and less polished team who got worse results. But I think they had an identity, they were a riverboat gambler style team, and were raved about by fans all across the league that we were the most exciting up & coming team in hockey. Today it just seems their identity is load up on as many washed up big name players as possible (Kane, Tarasenko, Wheeler) even if they don’t fit what the teams needs are (speed, forecheckers, puck moving dman).
It just seems there isn’t much of a plan. Like how we played shorthanded several games because Drury didn’t have the forethought regarding adding Kane at the deadline. I think if we kept with the identity of that 2019-20 team we would’ve evolved into something special. I get you don’t like Lemieux but guys like him and DeAngelo had a lot more swagger, edge, etc to them than much of our team today. I remember watching Tony go on a shootout when I believe he was something crazy like 6/6 in his career, he just had this laser focused expression on his face and you knew he knew he was going to score. So many times our team seems uninterested even in the playoffs, like they were okay with losing. Someone like Tony would get absolutely pissed and would play like he gave a shit even if that meant lashing out or dropping the gloves. That team was a lot of fun especially with Igor coming in and putting up insane numbers as a rookie call up. So many storylines that season.
I think when evaluating prospects or teams you want that elite gamebreaking talent and then you reel it in and get it under control and polish it where it’s rough around the edges. I think that 19-20 team was a high octane team that could’ve been one of the best in the league after a few years of polishing it up, a prototypical modern hockey team.