Remember that time Staal didn't play for like, 2 seasons, and everyone started to forget how good he was, and called him overrated?
Somehow, that's already happening with Stepan
Listen guys, I am not saying I want to see Sather offer-sheeted (I am a Ranger fan), I am just saying there would be a small part that feels he deserves it.
And if reports are correct Stepan has agreed to sign a bridge deal for 3.5 which is a considerable haircut compared to the recent deals of Kadri and Hodgeson. Anything less than that is Sather just screwing his own guy because of his horrible cap situation he has gotten himself into. Yes, if Stepan continues his trajectory he will sign a huge deal in two years regardless, but trying to pay him half of what he is worth based upon market value because of the cap situation Sather has gotten himself into is just wrong IMO.
If you don't see 3.5 as a more than fair deal for the Rangers I dunno what world you are living in. As a guy on national radio said yesterday, I'll paraphrase: "When Stepan says he will sign for 3.5 you immediately send a private jet to pick him up and sign the contract - I dunno what Sather is doing here unless it's all about not being able to sign him for that because of the cap and if that's the case maybe Brad Richards should have been bought out - If Stepan offers to play for 3.5 and you say no then call him out for holding out, there are major issues here, and it's not with the player, it's with the GM. - Stepan is a rare talent, could make the US Olympic team, is in the beginning of his career, and 3.5 is a total bargain when looking at market comparables - when and if the deal finally gets done or not this whole situation is horrible for a young guy who seems to want nothing more than to play for the team he was drafted for and is willing to get underpaid to do so - he just doesn't want minimum wage, because he has proved he is better, he scored the second most points in the NHL during the last 20 games last season and Sather is trying to pay him, what? nearldy half of what Kadri and Hodgeson got? This is insane. "
Regarding Sather, what horrible cap situation are you talking about? Sather knew exactly how much he was going to allot to re-signing Stepan. It was decided months ago that Stepan wouldn't get more than 2 years and we can easily afford to give him 3.5 mil. So where is this horrible cap situation?
Staal was an established #1 pairing D-man, for multiple 82 game seasons.
Stepan played like a #1 C for 48 games.
Not even close to comparable and on these Rangers boards, he is becoming overrated. People calling him a top 10 center, give me a break.
There's a huge difference between POTENTIAL and what he is now.
If you don't think the Richards contract isn't a bad cap situation I guess we will just have to disagree. But it's just one example of many over-paid over-aged players at the end of their career getting top dollar long term deals, Drury, Gomez, and Redden to name a few others. I don't see how Sather being the worst Salary cap GM is even arguable with his track record, but I guess it's an opinion.
But if you think Sather can afford 3.5 why don't we have anywhere near that in cap room right now and why isn't Stepan getting 3.5?
Why pay more than you need to. Just because you can spend 35k on a car doesn't mean you want to pay 35k if you don't have to. Maybe you want to leave some extra room for upgrades to the car and have a cap of what you want to spend at 32k.
If you don't think the Richards contract isn't a bad cap situation I guess we will just have to disagree. But it's just one example of many over-paid over-aged players at the end of their career getting top dollar long term deals, Drury, Gomez, and Redden to name a few others. I don't see how Sather being the worst Salary cap GM is even arguable with his track record, but I guess it's an opinion.
But if you think Sather can afford 3.5 why don't we have anywhere near that in cap room right now and why isn't Stepan getting 3.5?
Wow, I completely disagree, guess that's all there is to say.
Stepan showed his Potential, and that he found out how to stay consistent.
His first season, he put up 45 points. His next, 51 points. Third season? 44 points in HALF A SEASON.
It's pretty tough to overrate that.
I just think undercutting him that much is pointless, you don't have him in camp, might not even start the season. For what to underpay him by 70% instead of 80%. Doesn't make sense to me.
You completely disagree with basic math?
Maybe Stepan is a consistent 1st line center and his performance for half a season wasn't a fluke, but we'll never know until he signs.
I've been pretty patient and understanding throughout this ordeal, but if it extends through the season, I'll be super pissed at both Stepan and Sather. There's absolutely no reason for this to drag on, compromise instead of delaying the inevitable.
I am one of the biggest supporters of his holdout but....He put up nearly a ppg over HALF A SEASON.
When he puts up a PPG over a FULL season, then you can start calling him a top 10 center.
People are absolutely overrating him. Saying he's better than guys like E. Staal, P. Bergeron. Laughable.
A top 10 center is a joke.
I am one of the biggest supporters of his holdout but....
I agree he is absolutely not a top 10 center.
Probably not a top 20 center.
If he is the 30th best center in the league this year and signs for 3.5 he is still way way underpaid.
Thats the point. Rank him where you want. anywhere from 15-40 in most rankings.
The value for the 15th-40th center in the league far exceeds 3.5.
People may be over rating him for sure. 100%
But there are just as many people who under value his price.
What people dont wanna hear is that no matter how you slice it if he was arbitration eligible this year when you punch the numbers his worth is 5.5 million dollars. and he knows that and his agent know that....
If I was him I would ask for 1 year at 2.6
gets him arb eligible next year.
I thought about this. If it is true that the Rangers are willing to go to 3.2 from Brooks' article a few days ago then just out of curiosity why would you be pissed at slats?? Stepans camp gave on term. Sather is now upping the offer. This should have been a done deal the second 3.2 was offered.
The best part about this is, Stepan was god to like everyone 3 months ago
I disagree with your logic, not the math you use to back it up. No need to be *******, lol.