Toggle sidebar

Rangers Prospect Poll (Summer 2018): #7 Prospect

  • Xenforo Cloud has upgraded us to version 2.3.6. Please report any issues you experience.

#7 Prospect

  • Total voters
    116
  • Poll closed .
Harbour Dog said:
I dunno; I like Rykov, but it seems a little early.

Do you think that at the TDL we would of been able to trade Grabner for a second and the early rights to Miller (if Jersey had owned them for argument's sake)? I think they would of laughed at that offer.

Granted, Rykov's value to them may have been a little lower if they were concerned about him coming to NA, but not so much as for them to sell him at half value or anything so drastic.
Click to expand...

I’d rather base things on what I’ve watched. I think there’s way too much being based on what we are told.

For example, the Rangers through their mouthpiece Brooks told us they insisted on Hajek for the McDonagh trade. Are we sure that’s not to save face for not getting their way? I’m pretty sure there were also reports that Tampa wouldn’t trade Sergachyov or Foote.

And because of this, Hajek is somehow our fifth ranked prospect. There are people here who claim he’ll be the best defensemen on the NHL team this season. It’s not even clear that he has a real shot to make the NHL team.

And I don’t dislike Hajek, but I haven’t heard any “experts” talk him up that much, his stats are underwhelming, Tampa was willing to let him go but not the other two and I personally don’t regard him as highly as Howden or Rykov.

Neither of those guys gets any attention, and it seems like it’s because the team was caught in a pickle and now they are trying to sell us a bill of goods about Hajek basically being the McDonagh replacement we got in the trade for McDonagh. So of all the secondary prospects, he’s the guy everyone talks about. I just think we should pay more attention to what these players are doing and less to what the team is trying to sell us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CaptBagel
Pavel Buchnevich said:
I’d rather base things on what I’ve watched. I think there’s way too much being based on what we are told.

For example, the Rangers through their mouthpiece Brooks told us they insisted on Hajek for the McDonagh trade. Are we sure that’s not to save face for not getting their way? I’m pretty sure there were also reports that Tampa wouldn’t trade Sergachyov or Foote.

And because of this, Hajek is somehow our fifth ranked prospect. There are people here who claim he’ll be the best defensemen on the NHL team this season. It’s not even clear that he has a real shot to make the NHL team.

And I don’t dislike Hajek, but I haven’t heard any “experts” talk him up that much, his stats are underwhelming, Tampa was willing to let him go but not the other two and I personally don’t regard him as highly as Howden or Rykov.

Neither of those guys gets any attention, and it seems like it’s because the team was caught in a pickle and now they are trying to sell us a bill of goods about Hajek basically being the McDonagh replacement we got in the trade for McDonagh. So of all the secondary prospects, he’s the guy everyone talks about. I just think we should pay more attention to what these players are doing and less to what the team is trying to sell us.
Click to expand...
How about all the Tampa posters who were telling us how much Hajek's stock jumped up this season? How much have you watched of Hajek? Were you keeping a close eye on him during the WJC20s for the czech team? Or bought a package to watch him in Juniors?

Stats are underwhelming? Are you just going by his stats with everything? It doesn't seem like you know a whole lot about him aside from a lot of assumptions that brooks is feeding us info from the Rangers to save some face...which btw sounds incredibly ridiculous. .
 
  • Like
Reactions: darko
The Crypto Guy said:
How about all the Tampa posters who were telling us how much Hajek's stock jumped up this season? How much have you watched of Hajek? Were you keeping an eye on him during the WJC20s? Or bought a package to watch him in Juniors?
Click to expand...

So the Tampa fans said they liked him more than Foote?

I watched all the Czech games, and watched the WHL playoffs. I like Howden more from that trade, and I’d have Hajek no higher than second among D prospects. I’m not even sure he’s a better prospect than Lundkvist. I would probably give him the benefit of the doubt because he’s farther from his draft and still doing pretty well, but its a fair point to make that Nils has already shown well in a good men’s league. Hajek has been playing junior hockey.

Our fans act like Hajek projects as a top pairing D, yet I really don’t see where they get this from other than the team trying to cover themselves after trading away the captain. I don’t dislike the dude, but I think our fans overrate him based off what the team sells us.
 
Pavel Buchnevich said:
So the Tampa fans said they liked him more than Foote?

I watched all the Czech games, and watched the WHL playoffs. I like Howden more from that trade, and I’d have Hajek no higher than second among D prospects. I’m not even sure he’s a better prospect than Lundkvist. I would probably give him the benefit of the doubt because he’s farther from his draft and still doing pretty well, but its a fair point to make that Nils has already shown well in a good men’s league. Hajek has been playing junior hockey.

Our fans act like Hajek projects as a top pairing D, yet I really don’t see where they get this from other than the team trying to cover themselves after trading away the captain. I don’t dislike the dude, but I think our fans overrate him based off what the team sells us.
Click to expand...

Yes there are some saying his ceiling may hit that, so whats the big deal? I'm sure you see much higher ceilings than other posters on other players. It's our opinion. We aren't all going to agree on everything.
 
Pavel Buchnevich said:
So the Tampa fans said they liked him more than Foote?

I watched all the Czech games, and watched the WHL playoffs. I like Howden more from that trade, and I’d have Hajek no higher than second among D prospects. I’m not even sure he’s a better prospect than Lundkvist. I would probably give him the benefit of the doubt because he’s farther from his draft and still doing pretty well, but its a fair point to make that Nils has already shown well in a good men’s league. Hajek has been playing junior hockey.

Our fans act like Hajek projects as a top pairing D, yet I really don’t see where they get this from other than the team trying to cover themselves after trading away the captain. I don’t dislike the dude, but I think our fans overrate him based off what the team sells us.
Click to expand...

This is tinfoil hat territory.
 
  • Like
Reactions: darko
The Crypto Guy said:
Yes there are some saying his ceiling may hit that, so whats the big deal? I'm sure you see much higher ceilings than other posters on other players. It's our opinion. We aren't all going to agree on everything.
Click to expand...

There isn’t a big deal. I’m giving my opinion. You questioned me, which isn’t a big deal either. Isn’t the point of these threads to give our opinion on the rankings of our prospects and discuss the merits of where players should be ranked?
 
  • Like
Reactions: CaptBagel
Pavel Buchnevich said:
I’d rather base things on what I’ve watched. I think there’s way too much being based on what we are told.
...
And I don’t dislike Hajek, but I haven’t heard any “experts” talk him up that much, his stats are underwhelming, Tampa was willing to let him go but not the other two and I personally don’t regard him as highly as Howden or Rykov.
....
Click to expand...
Funny, you start with the premise of a need to be watching prospect to judge him and right away turn to support your take on a prospect by anything but...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Top Bottom