DJ Spinoza
Registered User
- Aug 7, 2003
- 25,984
- 4,580
The other thing worth keeping in mind throughout all of this is that most of Cherington's deals have tended to come out of nowhere because his front office doesn't seem like it has a lot of leaks, at least so far. I don't think that means we definitely won't get Rooker or Chisholm or Ward or Robert or whoever else is out there and publicly speculated on, but I think it's worth noting.Basically, nobody knows anything, and the team isn't in position for the national media to really care wholesale.....yet (hopefully).
This would be a dream result, I think. Winker makes a lot of sense and should not be too painful in terms of the prospects given up. Even if we "only" get him as a rental, it will be disappointing in one sense, but palatable for the risk/reward. I just don't know how we'll improve the outfield next year, though obviously trades are possible at the winter meetings.Right now, my goal for the deadline is Perez, Suwinski and Olivares out and Chisholm and Winker in. Winker is also awful defensively so he’s not a long-term fit, but he’s replacing 2 other OFers who are awful defensively so it’s not as problematic.
My hope is that they’d end up with:
1. Chisholm (CF)
2. McCutchen (DH)
3. Reynolds (LF)
4. Cruz (SS)
5. Winker (RF)
6. Tellez (1B)
7. Gonzales (2B)
8. Hayes (3B)
9. Bart (C)
Bench: Joe, Taylor, Grandal and Triolo
For a defensive sub, I figure Reynolds slides to RF, Chisholm slides to LF and Taylor gets put in at CF. I forgot that Palacios was up for Olivares already, it would suck to not have a spot for Palacios but I don’t really see one if they’re bringing in Chisholm and Winker.
If we assume only 1 main trade would happen, I am still on Chisholm, but I also think Arozarena could be a sweet spot. He's heating up which is something notable, and he's also a proven playoff and big game performer. It doesn't solve CF but I would be thrilled to end up with him.
My sense is still that Rooker is not in play and not really a good fit, though I also wonder for the sake of argument how we might feel with Rooker acquired and let loose in RF more often than seems stomachable right now, but at the cost of more regular playing time for Taylor in CF to at least give the OF a fighting chance.